Yes. I was all "I just have homegrown, backyard chickens from a local farm that is all organic - I don't need vaccines". Then I lost 12 new beautiful chicklets as they had not been vaccinated and apparently my current flock from the organic farmer was carrying Marek's as my vet confirmed they died of Marek's. Another chicken owner friend had bought another group of 12 chicks from the same person and didn't lose one, so it had to be my original flock that were hatched in my son's classroom from a local farmer. An experience you don't forget. Now I vaccinate all new chicks received for Marek's myself and I haven't lost a bird yet in the past 5 years and I get new chicks every year. Watch a youtube video on a chicken experiencing Marek's and ask yourself if you would ever want that to happen to one of yours.
Well, not necessarily. Marek's does not spread from hen to egg, so those eggs did not carry Marek's. Understand that Marek's is
everywhere and is so common that if you have birds, it's safe to say that they have been exposed to Marek’s, regardless of whether they show symptoms or not. Lack of biosecurity is one way that chickens can contract Marek's since the virus can be brought into your flock, for example, on the soles of your shoes after you picked up the active virus outside your property.
The question is, have the birds built up a resistance?
The Marek's vaccine does not prevent the chicken from getting Marek's disease. The vaccine keeps the tumors from forming that would eventually kill the bird and any bird that caught Marek's (it is highly contagious) from that bird. So your
vaccinated birds can have Marek's and spread Marek's but won't show symptoms themselves.
Opponents of the vaccine point to that as a reason NOT to have your birds vaccinated -- if they have Marek's, you'll never know it and the virus will be spread to unvaccinated birds that will die from it, which sounds like what happened in your case. By vaccinating them, you've made a whole flock of potential Typhoid Marys. If birds never leave your flock to go to another flock, that's not a big deal as long as every chick coming into the flock is vaccinated. A hen with Marek's resistance passes that resistance on to her chicks, but it only last for a few days, so vaccination is most effective if given within the first 24 hours after hatch.
If Marek's shows up in the flock, cull the affected birds and make it a strictly closed flock with strict biosecurity measures to prevent the virus from spreading. The only way to know whether your flock has Marek's is to not vaccinate them. I'm not an opponent of the vaccine, but I do see the logic in not having them vaccinated. It's a call we each have to make for our own flock.
Your flock has Marek's, so observe strict biosecurity measures so you don't carry the virus off your property.
https://extension.unh.edu/resources/files/Resource000791_Rep813.pdf