I totally should have seperated them, but being that they're backyard chickens and also have a third broody I was running out of places to keep them, and these two kept sharing eggs and I knew one hen had older eggs than the other, I don't know, big mistake on my part obviously.
It does have eyes, and they aren't stuck shut, it just doesn't seem to want to open them. It's feet are uncurling and it's fluffing up and peeping, but not a lot of movement going on. All of it's yolk and good stuff inside was gone when the bottom half of the shell came off, and no blood or anything (minus a small amount when Hen 2 yanked the still attached shell off, but that seems to be okay now). It's mother is fine once it gets under her, but I'm afraid with him being so small and frail he's going to get crushed by the other eggs and her big feet, so I think we'll set up the brooder. This is her (and the other hen's, and the other other hen's) first clutch, so this is all new to both of us. I don't want to over interfer, and it's probably not worth it, but I'd like to give this little one a start if nothing else. I'll stop by the feed store in the morning to check out some vitamin water.
It's opening it's mouth like a baby bird, I know it should have enough food, etc... for three more days, but should I be dipping it's beak in water?