For what it's worth, I have a copy of the SOP in my lap, opened for another issue at a show this weekend.
"NOTE: Feather leg breeds are not to be penalized for a rudimentary outer toe."
"Missing nail -1"
"Missing part of toe, each toe -1"
And don't think just because a bird came from different states, it is not related.
Lots of people are shipping eggs everywhere, they could possibly be closely related!
True!!