Silkies Need help sexing

[AnimalmomSarah]

I was told they’re both roosters, but the black silky is so sweet! They hatched out in August. Could the black silky be a hen?

 

[Crazy for Chickens!]

The black one is a pullet, and the Blue one is a Cockerel.

 

[Table4Six]

Both male. Handsome birds.

 

[ChickNanny13]

Can we get a better picture of their combs? Thinking Crazy for Chickens! got it.

 

[chickens really]

Rooster/Cockerel to me..

 

[Matzwd]

The stance alone of the black one says male to me, but the picture isn't clear enough to assess saddle or comb. The saddle and tail feathers along with the comb on the blue one would lead me to believe that's also a male.

 

[MillersFarm]

x2

 

[MrsEskew]

Both look like males to me. Silkie hens will have a more round poof on their head and you usually don't see their comb. Like my girl Goldie here...

 

[AnimalmomSarah]

Both look like males to me. Silkie hens will have a more round poof on their head and you usually don't see their comb. Like my girl Goldie here...
View attachment 1712569

She’s beautiful!

 

[AnimalmomSarah]

Can we get a better picture of their combs? Thinking Crazy for Chickens! got it.

I guess I don’t understand why one has a poof and the other does not.