So I shouldnt keep 2 Roo's? ~ Please help

mrsp523

Crowing
15 Years
Apr 23, 2010
185
44
271
Western Mass
Heres the issue. We have 12 one year old girls and 1 bantam roo. We have been incubating their eggs, with hopes to keep about 6-8 of the girls, the rest we have homes for. The person taking them can take straight run no problem because has family who takes in the roo's to find homes for them. Issue is of the first hatch we kept 7 knowing some might be roos, but...the big but...we saved one our chicks at hatch time, spent about 2 weeks nursing it, had a mini cast (plastic straw) then legs bandaided together. We said we were keeping this one as we have grown very fond of it. I say "it" but now at 4 plus weeks it is looking very much like a roo. I would not be able to send this one to freezer camp - way to attached, and he is super friendly with us right now.
I'm reading on here that having a 2nd roo join the group would be a huge problem, chances are he would be the bigger roo of the two in the end because his dad was a big RIR or NR, and mom was one of the same also. Am I just asking for trouble by trying to keep him? Or if I have enough females can these 2 regardless of age and size live happily in the same coop (free range 1/4 - 1/2 the day most months except the dead of winter). Were hoping to end up with 18-20 girls. Again the 12 older ones and 6-8 more intergrated late spring/summer. I would appreciated any and all advise...The bantom roo we have now is only a few months younger than the hens. We had to rehome our first roo who grew up with the flock because he got really mean to us, and spent more time chasing us out of our own yard than anything else.
I was thinking before reading up on this subject that a 2nd roo might actually help him out, he tends to get frustrated with just the 12 trying to keep them together. (Girls will be girls and they like to wander off in small groups sometimes and he doesnt like this at all.) But now I'm thinking "what I "think" is right and what "really" is right, is two differant things! Oh boy!
barnie.gif
 
I have two roos and 14 girls right now. They do work together in keeping tabs on where all the ladies are and in sounding the hawk alarm etc. I'm not a chicken expert, but I think it's definitely worth a try... your numbers are high enough it's feasible to have two roos and the rest will just be up to their personalities.
 
I have had several roos in my last small flock. Usually there will be one that will be dominant and the others will kind of pal around looking for predators. Just like TeamChaos said. Technically you can have one roo per five hens and have harmony. Of course individuals will vary. My next coop setup will have a bachelor flock for the extra roos. Because I dont think I could actually do freezer camp.
 
Okay this is good...so I have a chance (or they do..depending on their demeanor). I've been reading so much about how this could create big problems. I know how much space they have plays a roll in all this, and they will have plenty of free range time. We are buying a big shed that I am going to keep the younger group of chicks in for the spring...and into the summer. I thought they could free range during the day, and have shelter away from each other on off times. Then my husband is taking the shed back in the Fall, pulling out the roosts and such and using for winter storage (2 uses in one). At this time both groups should be ready to live in the same place.

smile.png
Thanks for responding! TeamChaos ~ I love your picture. "Almosta farm." My youngest daughter asked what we had to do to become an offical farm. As this year we are also getting a few pigs. I told her I thought we had to get a cow for that to happen.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the compliment, but the sign was there before *I* was- my mom and Grandma came up with it and made it so. So many people assume our family name is "Almosta". ha ha ha! I'd like to know what makes a farm official too!
 
It will all depend on your boys and how they take to each other. Some live in harmony, others don't. As for numbers, if you are looking to have 15-20 hens, you could use 2 roos for them. I have read one roo can handle up to 20, but I think around 10 is the ideal.
 
I have 3 roos with my laying hens, and 2, possibly 3 roos in my silkie pen-----they do have a minor skirmish now and then, but they get along fine the rest of the time.
smile.png
 
Thanks again BYC people
celebrate.gif
I really want to keep him....Out of the bunch he is one of a few that loves to hang out with us. I have 2 golden campine cross also who are turning out to be just like their mother...nosey, gotta be right there to see whats going on, jump up and down as if saying "pick me, pick me" but when you pick them up they act like your going to kill them. I just hope my guy doesnt have a temperment like his Dad...which wasnt very nice! I was told by someone that mean roo's tend to produce mean male offspring....boy I hope they were wrong!
fl.gif
 
I always keep a back-up roo... usually a father & son duo or two brothers. If the younger roo is raised with the head roo from the time he is a baby (or two brothers together), he will know his place in the pecking order. Never separate him (younger roo) from the flock for any length of time because then he becomes just another adult roo trying to usurp the Roodom. I would keep him!
frow.gif


Only problem would be wearing out the hens... depends on if the head roo lets him even try.
wink.png
 
The roos (we have several) work very well together, we only have one banty roo,
and the others range in size, but they all get along. And size doesn't necessarily
dictate where they'll be on the pecking order, either. (Just ask Pebbles, our banty
rooster....
smile.png
) It is cool to see them work together to keep the hens and their babies safe.
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom