Or, you can lick your finger, swipe your soap and lick your finger again. I tested ungelled soap with the tongue test onetime and it really felt like putting a batterie to your tongue. Not fun!
From what I have read, those tests are not very accurate for CP soap. I have never used them though.
If you are not sure that the soap gelled all the way, I would wait another week or two. Ungelled is fine, it just takes a little longer to complete the proccess.
Now, if you want to make a good man's soap, I would really reccomend a 100% Coconut oil soap with a 20% superfat. My hubby loves it. And it is not drying at all because of the very high superfat. But don't use a severe lye solution. This is a very hard recipe and it will crumble .
And if you did not anchor your orange eo with something like patch, it will fade rather quickly from the soap. I do 3 parts orange to 1.5 parts patch.