Split flock or say goodbye to 2nd rooster?

[Cluckatar]

His comb is slightly more red than the other three, but otherwise quite similar. I checked the many dozen pics, but I just can't find one close up that I'm certain is him. I'm going by the tail and his general attitude. He's the guy who jumps up on the extra feeder and stares you down. And he will occasionally fly over to chest bump into the larger Marans rooster. Thankfully that one ignores him for the most part. He's enough bigger that he doesn't have to care.

 

[Cluckatar]

Goofy low angle shots, but I "think" he is the one on top in the first pic, and on the far left in the other. My daughter took these, so I can't be sure. That tells you how much I'm going by tail to tell them apart.

 

[afieldssnowyegger]

These are from a week or two ago, but here’s my suspect, Fluffy.

Also, if you think you have a boy and you ordered a girl, My Pet Chicken will refund if you notify them once the chicken is between 10-18 weeks old.

 

[afieldssnowyegger]

These are from a week or two ago, but here’s my suspect, Fluffy.View attachment 2183718View attachment 2183719
Also, if you think you have a boy and you ordered a girl, My Pet Chicken will refund if you notify them once the chicken is between 10-18 weeks old.

Fluffy’s comb has grown a good bit since the picture was taken, but that was at 6-7 weeks

 

[Folly's place]

At this age, it's about the combs, and not the tails.
I have five bantam EEs right now, almost seven weeks old, and it's becoming fairly obvious who's who. Once in a while a cockerel will develop later though.
Mary

 

[Cluckatar]

We originally ordered one rooster and four hens for the Snowy EE, and one hen with two straight run on the silver cuckoo marans. The available numbers were really low so we took our chances. We've been surprised by how much we like the marans rooster, and one of our original EEs died in transit, so we haven't been certain if there would be an EE rooster. They gave us a prompt refund at the female chick price which was nice.

 

[afieldssnowyegger]

To me, it looks like you have the rooster still.

 

[Cluckatar]

I tried again, and here are some comb close ups. First is Snowy the suspected rooster. Second two are a couple of the probably hens with a repeat.

 

[afieldssnowyegger]

I tried again, and here are some comb close ups. First is Snowy the suspected rooster. Second two are a couple of the probably hens with a repeat.

I’m 99% sure that the first pic is your rooster.

 

[Cluckatar]

I still have both suspected roosters at week 11 now. The Silver Cuckoo Marans is 1000% a rooster and is trying to crow. The Snowy White Easter Egger, I'm still pretty sure is a rooster. This morning I found Dirty Dan (the Marans roo) swinging him in circle by a neck feather while Snowy squacked like crazy. So I'm feeling like I really want to re-home the Snowy EE guy soon.