I also had pasty butt with the MHP. I have 4 different breeds of chicks but it was only one of the breeds, and all of those. I suspect it was something in that breed, not with the brooder set up or anything.
X2 on using olive oil.

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I also had pasty butt with the MHP. I have 4 different breeds of chicks but it was only one of the breeds, and all of those. I suspect it was something in that breed, not with the brooder set up or anything.
X2 on using olive oil.
I'm really surprised that any of your chicks have pasty butt.....you are the first person who has reported that with MHP and I'm so sorry! I haven't had any since my first batch of chicks, and they were raised under a heat lamp. I remember being so frustrated because I couldn't imagine how 22 chicks ended up with 144 hineys to clean.You can certainly try the apple cider vinegar in their water. Do you mind if I ask a few questions in case it comes up in the MHP thread? Any information we share helps others, right?![]()
When you clean it off, can you either slightly trim the down from around the vent?(not enough to make a target for the others to peck at and irritate, just enough to reduce the down the poop has to stick to)
Did you try dabbing a small amount of olive oil, coconut oil, or Vaseline if that's what you have on hand, on the down around the vents to make poop less likely to stick?
Are they in a lighted room all night long or do the lights go out at sunset so they aren't eating 24/7?
Did they already have pasty butt when you got them?
That "hiding chicks" is the biggest drawback to MHP, but then I can't look at them under a broody either - at least not when it's Attila the Hen out there. When she's broody I don't even to out to the coop without chain mail, a helmet, gauntlets, and a sword! But I found that if I just lift up the front of the "cave", they are all right there.
I wish you all the best of luck, and again, I'm sorry you are having such a hard time.
I would brood outside, in a garage or shed maybe? Or get busy with the coop...Another first timer chiming in here. My on-grade block foundation is done and coop construction begins on 3/10. We are building The Garden Loft.
Ten chicks arrive 3/13 via my local southern states. Here are the breeds:
Araucana (2)
Barred Rock
White Leghorn
Black Australop
Rhode Island Red
Buff Orpington
Golden Laced Wyandotte
Welsummer (2)
I picked up a combo Craigslist deal of a 4'x4'x2' brooder box (and a 2'x2' insert for when they are tiny) along with a chick feeder, waterer, and three lamps. But given this thread and the dust concerns I am starting to consider the MHP and outdoor method. I can't brood from the beginning in the coop because the coop isn't built yet. Debating whether to brood them outdoors in the brooder box. Any thoughts?