Quote: My personal opinion (for what it's worth)...
I believe it might be a good idea to "rank" faults so that everyone is on the same page.
IOW, sprigs or carnation comb wouldn't be near as serious of a fault as a split wing.
Just one example.
We all work to breed toward perfection... but let's face it, the perfect bird doesn't exist.
Now... from another perspective....
We've bred show sheep for years. I'm a big fan of line breeding, but also know when it's wise to go "outside" a line.
None of us have enough genetics to go either way with SFH yet, but the point is, almost always when we go "outside a line", we breed to something that has a fault.
WHY? Because that same animal has a quality that is so high on the perfection standard that we need to use it to improve that quality in our own line.
But what about the faulty trait that comes with the high quality trait?
That's where responsible breeding comes in... it's a combination of all the right genetics, but it's also throwing mud against a wall and seeing what sticks.
In my opinion, we are too early in the game to throw the baby out with the bath water.
I say we call carnations and/or sprigs a "fault" to be bred out... but culling is different than breeding out. It's a fault but not as serious a fault as other faults.
Genetics 401... Not every animal in my barn is a show animal... but every animal when crossed with the correct complimentary animal "could" produce a show animal.
You have to take it a generation at a time and as long as each generation is an improvement on it's parents, then you are doing something right.
if you've got a copy of the APA standard, the best thing to do is read any breed's standard. usually the first thing on the list is size. every breed has a specific weight range for pullets/hens/cockerels/cocks... next on the list is type. what the bird's overall shape should be, including wing and tail carriage, stature (upright vs horizontal stance). then come more minor things like combs and color (though in SFH that is not an issue as long as they're mottled)...