Taking the leap and starting with our first 25 - help me pick!

By heritage, do you mean American heritage or are you open to others. In my opinion, some other dual purpose breeds to consider are Australorp, Dorking, Orpington, Favorelle and any of the Rocks or Wyandotte. The Rocks and Wyandottes are American, the others are not. I'm sure I am missing some.

I'm not sure what kind of problems you are thinking about. If you get 5 straight run chicks from a reputable nuesery, here are the odds of the sexes you'll get. Packing peanuts are not considered and will probably be roosters, which distorts the odds.

5 male 0 female - 1 in 32 or 3.1%
4 male 1 female - 5 in 16 or 15.6%
3 male 2 female - 10 in 16 or 31.3%
2 male 3 female - 10 in 16 or 31.3%
1 male 4 female - 5 in 16 or 15.6%
0 male 5 female - 1 in 16 or 3.1%

If you free-range the different breeds together, you will mostly wind up with mutts. For me, that is not a problem. I like mutts. If you want to keep the breeds pure, you need to separate each breed in the coop and run all the time once they start egg-laying.

The recommended ratio of hens to roosters is 10 or 12 to 1 for full-sized chickens. One problem with a lower ratio is that the roosters can injure hens with their spurs by excessive mating. Regardless of the ratio of hens to roosters, there will be dominance issues with the roosters. These tend to be more frequent with fewer hens for each rooster. What will normally happen is that the dominance will be settled, at least for a while, and the roosters act as a team to protect the flock. Each rooster gets his share of sexual favors, but the dominant one gets first choice. Sometimes, though, there will be severe injury and death from these dominance fights. It depends if the losing rooster will accept the assistant position and second choice. As long as the hen-rooster ratio is high enough, you usually don't have big problems. Another thing that can help is to have separate feeding and watering facilities. This somewhat reduces the territorial issues and dominance fights.

If two roosters share a coop, try to keep the roosts all the same elevation. This could reduce the dominance issues on where they get to roost. The dominant one likes to be higher.

Hope this helps.

Edited to add: Buckeye and Chantecler as possible breeds to consider.

 

I don't know if you've seen this chart but it's a great way to see what color/how many eggs each breed lays: http://www.ithaca.edu/staff/jhenderson/chooks/chooks.html

If you want some reliable egg layers in the mix I would go with some ee's (americanas), RIRs or one of the other good layers. Also, have you checked out www.mypetchicken.com? You can order individually by breed as pullets or cockerels - that way you won't have a bunch of roos that you need to get rid of or put in rooster jail.

Another website that's great is www.feathersite.com - you can do tons of research on each breed.

Have fun picking them out!

 

here's my 2 cents worth

5 - Americauana, colored eggs
5 - Black Australorps, brown eggs & super sweet
5 - Buckeyes, brown eggs & really cool heritage breed
5 - White Austras, creamy white eggs & feathers (i like the contrast to the others)
5 - Welsummers, I don't have these yet but the super dark eggs are appealing in mix
Good luck!

 

Another idea that just came to me is that Murray McMurray has an ornamental or rainbow layer collection... I think each is 25 pullets. You could then order one of each roo that you want.

 

I have only just begun my flock (7 hens and a chick I think might be a rooster), but a breed I have been looking into lately for the future is the White Faced Black Spanish. They look like an extremely pretty breed, and they are supposed to be dependable, calm, non-setting layers of large white eggs. I'm thinking about getting a few next year. You should look into them. I believe Murray McMurray and Ideal both carry them.
It would be very interesting to breed them as they are so rare.

If I could choose 25 for you, I'd choose these:

5 White Faced Black Spanish
5 EEs (lovely eggs and great temperament as well)
5 RIRs (one of the best laying breeds)
5 Brahmas, any color (for dependable winter laying)
5 Dominiques/Dominickers (great heritage breed - said to be the oldest American breed)

And, if you could fit them in, Welsummers and Speckled Sussex (my SS chick is feathering out beautifully).

Before you take the plunge, you should listen to some advice from more experienced flock owners than myself.

Hope this helps!

 

I agree with the other posts. It's difficult to say what you should get for breeds. If you asked a lot different people you would probably get many different answers. Some may agree on the breeds. Here is a great reference book, Gail Damerow's 'Storey's Guide to Chickens' is an excellent resource, as well as this web site which is an excellent source of information.

These sites are especially helpful in selecting breeds.
http://www.mypetchicken.com/breedQuestions.aspx
Henderson's Chicken Breed Chart
http://www.feathersite.com/Poultry/BRKPoultryPage.html

Also here are some other good sites and info and more good links.
http://www.mypetchicken.com/aboutChickens.aspx
https://www.backyardchickens.com/lcenter.html
https://www.backyardchickens.com/coopdesigns.html
https://www.backyardchickens.com/web/viewblog.php?id=2593-Treats_Chart

 

Since you are just planning a flock, I would suggest several different kinds. Get a couple hens & 1 roo of each. After the first year you will have a better understanding of each. I ordered 15 different breeds and will keep RIR, BO, SS and a roo of each and brown leghorn, BL, BR, SLW, SL Hamburg female only. A good variety of brown & white egg layers. Although in my cold climate, will most likely not replace the white egg layers.
lol