Thanx for this post ya’ll !
I’ve been here for 2 years learning & planning for my first coop and read just about everything . We have 5 acres & I use 5-6 feeding stations for
Birds , so squirrels are ABUNDANT !!
sounds like the “grandpa” treadle is the way to go ? Was on the fence til this post .. .
Uhhhh, no. Those guillotine feeders are so slow to train that the rats and squirrels find out where the feed is and just push the lid open on the grandpa feeders. Look on the
Amazon reviews for their feeder, you will find this video posted and others.
And squirrels are fairly large critters, up to two pounds, so you have to have full sized birds and have the spring tension set for a five pound bird. Let the bantams and silkies eat from the side when the larger birds are eating. But even a ground squirrel can open the grandpa feeder and they weigh in ounces, not pounds. Like two ounces, one eight of a pound for the small ones and up to 8 ounces or half a pound for the larger varieties. Here is one video showing two chipmunks pushing open a grandpa feeder and chowing away.
The grandpa feeder will work for light infestations or if you don't already have rats, mice, wild birds, or a squirrel problem. They work sometimes with light infestations where the flock owner just gets lucky and has a bird that doesn't take two weeks to get over its fear of that guillotine lid coming down on its head. But look at their
Amazon reviews, between 72 and 66% five star rating. If you have a product that fails to meet expectations 28 to 34% of the time you need to redesign your product. Yes, there will always be idiots like the one lady complaining that her kid jumped on the treadle and ruined it, but at the same time a treadle ought to be able to handle the abuse, our feeder could take that abuse, a single robust flat steel bar instead of five flimsy parts pop riveted together including two 1/2" pvc pipes. If you are just selling a chicken feeder, 72% five star rating wouldn't be bad, but if you are claiming to be rat proof, wild bird proof, mouse proof, and squirrel proof and nearly one third of your customers are upset you have a design failure.
https://www.amazon.com/Grandpas-Fee...ll_reviews&filterByStar=critical&pageNumber=1 And do a search on
Amazon, why does the same manufacture have multiple product listings? Spreading out the bad reviews is my opinion.
But if you do go with the grandpa design look at the clones like Rent a coop or Neatfil, much cheaper, they fixed a few of the problems with the Grandpa design, they are cheaper than the grandpa feeder, then again they still have that same 25% or worse disapproval rating. Not sure of the Neatfil seller, they are claiming that raccoons can't get to the feed, that has to be an outright lie. But you have these Chinese sellers coming in hoping to make a quick buck on a copy of a product that costs them 15% of what it sells for, they can handle some returns.