Before you assume substandard judgement is in play, please consider the slur that you're inferring on these people's experience, knowledge and years spent devoted to the fancy. I believe one of the judges has been an APA past president and probably knows the difference between a Buckeye and a RIR.
You'd think but as broad as the standard is its plausible that it could be interpreted many different ways......they judged them to the best of their abilities and that is all that we ask.....right. It's not like there is a set of scales at each isle......every person sees things differently!! Kind of explains the orange buckeyes out there; but we all live to show another day!!