Hello Outrun Acres,
Three days ago, I subscribed Ameraucana thread, and am deeply sorry that I did! The reason for my joining the group was to find out about "true Ameraucana birds, so to be able to purchase some. Your response to my questions was very kind, and helped me to find this thread. Also, another very pleasant breeder contacted me via the PM., which I really appreciate both responses; thank you!
My question on the Ameraucana thread was asked honestly, and innocently, without any intentions of starting a nasty debate. I was completely unaware of the never ending, very unpleasant, and at times quite rude disagreements. My question in short was: "if they have, ABC. accepted colors, they are classified as;Ameraucana, and if they are any other color, they are EE. I am having difficulty understanding how they can be classified as different breed if they are the progeny of the same parents?" Rules of genetics can not be changed at someone's whim.
I subscribed to BYC in the hopes of finding good, responsible breeders to purchase the birds I would like to have in my life. I feel very lucky to have found 2 excellent breeders of Orpingtons, and HRIR, to add several birds to my small menagerie. Past Nov., I bought a lovely, gorgeous Ameracuana pullet from a person and paid good money for, which I believe she is worth every penny of it. Yes, she started to lay bluest of the blue eggs. But, recently I've found out that she is NOT an Ameraucana, but an EE. Actually, I am no longer sure what she is. The main reason for me to be on the other thread was to learn, and hopefully find a breeder; instead, unknowingly, I touched a very sensitive nerve which ended up causing yet another controversy. My, oh my! it was only an honest single post! It was a mistake; but, a good lesson to learn from. I will never go onto the Ameraucana thread ever again; even if they are the only ones left on the face of the earth! What I feel sorry are the poor birds..
I am very involved in the dog show world, and we look at the new comers into our breeds with gratitude, and treat them kindly; answer their questions however much they may seem funny, or unbelievable. If we shun and chase them out of our breed, they will go on to the next one, and we will end up being the looser. New comers into any breed of animals are the future of that breed. If we don't have the novice to mentor, share our quality animals with, to continue to improve the breed, and to carry our banner, it shall become no-more in good time..
Thank you for your kind words. I am so sorry they decided to spew their venom at you too. I absolutley love this thread and know you will too. I did recently start a new Ameraucana thread for all the dissatisfied subscribers on the other one. I only started it yesterday and am hoping it will take off. So far it is doing fairly well. Some very nice people have joined as well as some knowlegable breeders. One of them was actually involved in creating Ameraucana breed and getting it approved as an APA breed. So far the atmosphere has been very pleasant and it seems everyone just wants to learn more about the breed and share their own personal experiences. Please come join us over there as well.
I agree with everything you just said. My background in centered around dogs as well as horses and production animals. I have a small background in genetics and some of the statements other subscribers made on that thread really made my brain hurt, because it just didn't make good scientific sense.
Here is the link to the new Ameraucana Breed Thread:
https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/...n-standard-and-project-birds/50#post_10625506