I have good hatches of all other breeds, anywhere form 60-80% at least, some breeds 100%. I have only hatched one legbar from about 2 dozen eggs. Got some due tomorrow and anxious to see if I get any. I am going to try to use a broody next. I do a pretty good dry hatch except for 3 days of hatching the previous eggs that are in the incubator. I have two groups going at a time. Last hatching I even took the legbars and put into another incubator to hatch and none hatched. I will keep trying. Yes, they are sisters I assume because they came from eggs I got last year from one breeder, probably but not for sure.
Although all my eggs hatched but when I placed them in the bator, the air cells were very small, almost non-existent. So maybe you do have a point, thats why dry hatching works better for them. I also read somewhere that Maran eggs get a better hatch rate if they are lightly sanded before incubation. It does get rid of the bloom and increases the risk of introducing germs, however it also removes a layer of brown pigment that would make evaporation from the egg easier.
I would totally agree that there is a definite difference with the CCL eggs. Just as an example,when I crack eggs to cook I can give a couple of ok whacks to most of the eggs without doing more than cracking them, but the same force on the CCL eggs will shatter them. I think the shells are significantly weaker, despite all of my breeds receiving the same diet of Flock Raiser, oyster shells (free to any that want them), and a full acre to free-range on.