Y'know, I'm of two minds on this. If someone comes on and says, "look, I have (insert name of breed here), too, then the appropriate response is to say, "Good for you, welcome to the breed, this is a great place to learn about them, etc." Jumping right in with "Those things are soooo far from show quality that they are an embarrassment to the breed name, I hope you aren't so misguided that you intend to breed those ratty things" is totally uncalled for. On the other hand, if they ask, "what do you think?" there are still ways of being honest without being brutal. You don't have to call them walking yard waste or fox food to suggest that they don't meet the SOP.
But mentioning hatchery birds, I pulled an egg out of a pen today that I believe to be the first effort of an EE pullet. It's cream colored.