I told her if they tried to put it through my bank again I would call the police and press charges!
Well, that was pointless.
I understand your frustration, but who, exactly, are you going to press charges against? PayPal? PayPal is not trying to steal your money. On the couple of occasions when we have disputed charges with PayPal, they were very courteous, very professional, and dealt with the situation themselves in a quick and efficient manner (resolution of the case within a few days). Either someone at PayPal slipped up, or the thief tried again from another angle, but getting all worked up like this isn't helping your blood pressure or you. You have covered your bases, so now it's in the hands of the professionals whose job it is to sort these things out. Getting all hot and bothered and making meaningless threats will just get you the reputation of being a crazy old lady, which only makes customer service folks less likely to help you.