Sorry for posting three separate times in a row here, last night I was on mobile and now I'm on the work computer so I can really type. Kinda feels like I'm being pesty, haha.
I've been chewing on breeding goals and possibilities, especially in regard to the barred variety in particular. I know I'm already breaking Bob Blosl's (and many other wise breeders') cardinal rule in that I'm crossing lines. But honestly, I simply couldn't carry on with a male of the Good Shepherd line from where I acquired the pullets, for various (semi-personal, semi- anti- that line in particular) reasons. So, I'm doing the next best thing, starting where I am with what I have.
What I have is a Kraig Shafer cock(erel), 5 Good Shepherd hens, and one pullet chick from a third breeder in Arizona that has tighter feathering than either other line I have.
My hens are not laying well. They laid okay last year, but weren't magnificent. Something else that bothers me is that their eggs are still what I consider quite small, as second year hens no less. Plus, I want to tighten up the fluff considerably. The hens I would say are fair, the cock(erel) is quite fluffy.
The laying and feather issue is what's currently rolling around my mind, as Bob already told us exactly how to fix both of those issues: select for the fastest maturing chicks and keep doing that. The problem being, crisp barring is produced by the slowest feathering birds. So, I have a bit of a conundrum. Do I pressure them into faster and faster feathering and improve the rate of lay and feather quality, but lose the crisp barring? Is that something that I can add back in later? Do I let them all grow out and try to determine which nicely-barred birds are better than others? Pondering.
It will be interesting to see what I end up with after doing the dreaded outcrossing. Ideally, I'd love to get a cockerel chick with tighter feathering and a deeper/fuller/rounder breast, to replace my current male in some breedings. I might get a pile of crap, too

That's what the experienced breeders say I'll get, so I'm sure it's more than likely. We shall see how much work I have ahead of me. Or maybe a Good Shepherd male that actually has the tail and wing carriage I want will materialize, who knows. I'm going to keep those hens for as long as they keep going, anyway.