The road less traveled...back to good health! They have lice, mites, scale mites, worms, anemia, gl

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have always fed the same feed to all my birds. I do purchase chick grow for incubated chicks, because, they are not learning from an adult. However they get the same as everyone else as soon as they hit the ground. Baby's will go to the adult bowl and copy anyway, so it makes no sense to feed differently. I love it when other chickens teach the chicks what to eat.
 
Which food?  People or chickens? 

I've heard all that layer mash will hurt the chick's kidneys claptrap on BYC and there have been no studies that I could find to confirm that...just theories.  Tell my 6 yr old birds out there how bad it is for their kidneys...they haven't gotten the message yet.  :rolleyes:    Before they were turned over to other people, I still had 15 of the original flock of 30 ordered as chicks that year...I culled some for nonlay, a few of the production breeds and Doms died of heart failure in the second year(pretty normal for hatchery stock) and the rest were laying like gang busters into their 5 th year.  Right behind them was a whole flock of 6 mo. old birds coming into lay...all healthy as horses.  They did well...so did the meaties in the past and the last ones this spring.  And all the other chicks I raised on it. 

I once fell for that and thought, maybe I should use flock raiser instead of layer when I integrate my 2 wk old chicks back into the flock with mama, even used chick starter for the first 2 wks...but looked around at my thriving flock and their great performance and thought better of it.  Same with the rooster...he eats layer.  Many will tell you that, since he doesn't lay, he cannot utilize the calcium. Have you SEEN the leg bones on this rooster???  All my roosters have eaten layer ration. 

Tell me this one....babies drink milk.  All mammalian babies drink milk for the first months of their lives.  That very high calcium diet does what?  Build strong bones for good growth.  Not a kidney failure in a one of them.  Granted bird kidneys are different than mammals...but not much. 

By the time I have chicks in my layer flocks, they are eating 100% layer mash...no whole grains.  I also give my chicks BOSS within the first 2-3 days of their being here~throw some in the bedding and watch the show.  Lets mama teach them how to forage, right there in the brooder and it also teaches those without a mama to do the same. 

 
Why do you think so many say such a thing though? Even people doing this for years advise against it. Even the folks in our community who have been raising birds for over 50 years have them on grower. Do you feed layer because of it's availability? Because of price?

Sorry for all the questions. I'm curious.. I started feeding layer to chicks when I first started, and they all slowly faded away. IT was terrible.

So after doing a bit of research... Thinking that since my birds don't rely solely on their feed for 100% of their diet, they should be able to find what they need to balance the calcium properly.

But is layer REALLY necessary? The only difference in values is the calcium when compared to my grower feed. Wouldn't they get adequate calcium from forage, and scraps?

Only had a shelless egg a few times. Once from one hen, she was culled for issues. The other one, it must have been a first egg, because I haven't seen any since.
 
Last edited:
I have always fed the same feed to all my birds. I do purchase chick grow for incubated chicks, because, they are not learning from an adult. However they get the same as everyone else as soon as they hit the ground. Baby's will go to the adult bowl and copy anyway, so it makes no sense to feed differently. I love it when other chickens teach the chicks what to eat.
All my birds eat the same food as well. Grower with 16% protein.
 
Well, it's about time you came on up on the porch!
smile.png
Saw you around but didn't know you. What a great opportunity for you to raise chickens with a built in farm handy. Funny that your BAs aren't carrying their weight...I've always found mine to be laying when no one else was. But...hatchery genetics vary.

I think you will like doing meaties with FF...I was shocked at the difference in feed use, smell and activity levels on the FF.

So nice to finally "meet" you! One question....how did you get that lovely font on your post?
pop.gif
Just use Italics.
 
I'll tell you a little story about a small town business.  I buy batteries for my dog's collar and could only find them at Radio Shack 45 miles away..which is pretty inconvenient if you thought you had one left in the pack and find you didn't.  Now the dog is wearing a collar with no battery and you have to drive 45 mi. to get some. 

One day I am in the local hardware store and there, right by the counter, are the batteries I've needed and they were only 4 mi. away!  I gushed, "Wow!  You are selling these for $6.95???  I've been paying $9.99 at Radio Shack for them!  From now on I'm getting my batteries here!". 

The next time I stopped in for batteries the price was $7.95.  I looked at the fella and asked, "You raised those because I told you how expensive they were at Radio Shack, didn't you?".  He blushed, kind of shrugged his shoulders in a sheepish manner and said that he had. 

My reply?  "And you wonder why small businesses are going out of business?  GREED.  I'll find my batteries elsewhere."  And I did...for $6.95 at the local feed store.  Who didn't, BTW, raise their prices when I told them how much cheaper they were than RS. 

May seem only a dollar's difference to you, but to me it was a strong indication of why small businesses go out of business.  I've seen this all my life.  I'll tell you why....they gouge prices on rural customers because they know they are the only game in town. 

https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/644300/fermenting-feed-for-meat-birds


It's kind of a mute point now as internet shopping has made goods available to all at lower prices ....

I'll tell you a story... I used to work in a small office just 2 of us.... Keeping a big jug of milk in the fridge wasn't practical we didnt have the space or need for that much milk.... There was a little store on the lower floor of our bldg. everyday or so I'd go down and buy a little container of milk. Well after the earthquake here I went down to get our milk and the guy looked me in the face and charged me a dollar more.... For a TINY container of milk. There wasnt a shortage he was just being greedy!!! I questioned him but had to pay his price as my boss wanted milk. Well next day I went down with exact change slammed it on the counter and walked out with my milk. I hate that behavior and I'd avoid that store too :D
 
And Bee, here is more with Fred's Hens being the OP

https://www.backyardchickens.com/t/728385/roosters-and-calcium-whats-the-current-thinking

The way I read that study is that most if not all layer feed is a very poor diet for Roosters that are meant for breeding.
The reason I say this is because most if not all layer feed contains a Calcium level over 2% and is much closer to 4%.

I still believe that a good Starter, Grower or Starter/Grower feed is best feed for male chickens. 


Chris


http://202.196.80.249/jpkc/myhexiuyuan/gout/008.pdf
There you go. Something to read :)

Those with mixed flocks, young birds, moulting birds, cockerels, cock birds, chicks, as well as layers, find that feeding everyone a single feed much simplier.  Layer feed is only indicated for a laying hen, that's all.  It's target is too narrow, while Grower, Raiser or Starter can be fed to all.

Then, a calcium source can be provided for the laying hens, on the side.  Only they need the extra calcium and only they should eat the calcium.

Layer Feed is simply Grower with a heavy dose of calcium ground right in.  This is done merely for convenience.  There's nothing magical about Layer.  It isn't necessary at all.
 
Last edited:
Quote:
I've been doing it for years and I don't advise against it.
wink.png
I feed it because it works and doesn't harm my flocks and I don't have to worry about providing supplemental calcium to some of the production type layers in my flock that need it, like Little Red and some of the BAs I've had, in the winter. I don't change up feeds often and, yes, I do think the free ranging helps with calcium levels.

Everyone has different results in their flocks according to breed, breed source, feed, feed source, type of feeding system, etc. I have had different results than most and it could be that when I have chicks, the bulk of their nutrition is not from that feeder...mama has them out on free range in short order and their gullets are filled to bursting by the time I feed in the evening.

Hence, my advocating free range, chicks in the spring and not the fall, getting the family out of the brooder at 2 wks and onto pasture/foraged feeds, ACV in the water.

No one is choking layer feeds down anyone's elses throats here, so no need to go all linky on me.
wink.png
What I feed works and it has nothing to do with price. Yes, I've read all those articles and more when the first person went haywire like this on me when I mentioned I fed layer to chicks, way back when I came to BYC. Got the same info pulled out of the bra and waved in my face...didn't work then either.
roll.png


Proof? I have healthy birds....on the other hand, I see them~said bra info ladies~ over in the NEED HELP FAST section of the grocery store all the time.

Keep on feeding what you've read in the books, y'all, and I'll keep doing it my way, folks...no need to get all rowdy. I've got it all in hand and my birds are still producing in their geriatric years with beautiful white urates on their feces.
 
I've been doing it for years and I don't advise against it.  ;)   I feed it because it works and doesn't harm my flocks and I don't have to worry about providing supplemental calcium to some of the production type layers in my flock that need it, like Little Red and some of the BAs I've had, in the winter.  I don't change up feeds often and, yes, I do think the free ranging helps with calcium levels.

Everyone has different results in their flocks according to breed, breed source, feed, feed source, type of feeding system, etc.  I have had different results than most and it could be that when I have chicks, the bulk of their nutrition is not from that feeder...mama has them out on free range in short order and their gullets are filled to bursting by the time I feed in the evening. 

Hence, my advocating free range, chicks in the spring and not the fall, getting the family out of the brooder at 2 wks and onto pasture/foraged feeds, ACV in the water.

No one is choking layer feeds down anyone's elses throats here, so no need to go all linky on me.  ;)   What I feed works and it has nothing to do with price.  Yes, I've read all those articles and more when the first person went haywire like this on me when I mentioned I fed layer to chicks, way back when I came to BYC.  Got the same info pulled out of the bra and waved in my face...didn't work then either.  :rolleyes:  

Proof?  I have healthy birds....on the other hand, I see them~said bra info ladies~ over in the NEED HELP FAST section of the grocery store all the time. 

Keep on feeding what you've read in the books, y'all, and I'll keep doing it my way, folks...no need to get all rowdy.  I've got it all in hand and my birds are still producing in their geriatric years with beautiful white urates on their feces. 

 
I wasn't trying to get rowdy at all, hope you didn't sense that :/ Just thought I'd see if you saw valid points in what I posted.

It works for you. I would LIKE it to work for me, as it's the only feed available in the mash form in my area. I just want to make sure it's the right decision.

Is this your oldest flock?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom