thumping when candled - is it dead

im not to sure , if hes alive you should see a little movement , dont through the egg away yet let an expert tell you best of luck

 

Sorry, I am having a hard time trying to get a good visual of what you are seeing. If you are in doubt about wheter an egg is good or not you are better off to hold onto it to be on the safe side. How does it look in relation to the other eggs you are candling? Can you see any veining or is it just a blob free floating with nothing around it?

 

At 12 days, you should see some veining and a little movement. If you are not quite sure, I would give it another week. If you still don't see movement then, I would say it died. Good luck!

 

i had one like that at 13 days. i took it out. i never saw any movement in it and it just felt wrong. like there was just a ball in there or something. mine didn't have an air cell either.

 

I had one like that. The blob was larger than the moving chicks in the other eggs so.... I cracked it open. STINK!!!! It had at some point been a developing chick but had died. It was brown and icky fluid filled. I'll only ever open a questionable one like that outside. Hopefully you don't have what I did.

 

Smell the egg. I had an egg just last night that I questioned and it smelled, very little but it definitely had a smell to it compared to the others. I took it outside and opened it and it was definitely dead, my son quickly covered his mouth and nose because once opened the smell was worse. Glad I pulled it, would hate for that to explode in the bator.