Too many roosters

I've always heard 10:1 is perfect.

In certain kinds of commercial or large-scale situations, yes.

That's based on having hundreds of hens, wanting all eggs to be fertile for hatching, but not wanting to have extra roosters eating feed. Basically, big hatchery conditions. And even then, it's often a bit different for different breeds--Leghorns might be 12:1 while Brahmas might be 8:1.

The fewer chickens you have, the more their individual temperaments matter. So one rooster might have 20+ hens and some have bare backs from over-mating, while another rooster might have only 2 hens and they are fine. A particular pair of roosters might get along fine, while a different pair does not.

If you intend to hatch chicks regularly, I definitely recommend you come up with a plan for future cockerels--eat them, sell them, give them away, build a big bachelor coop and keep them, build many chicken coops and purchase dozens of hens so each one gets his own flock... There are many possibilities, although some are cheaper or more convenient than others :)
 
Since you will be hatching more, consider learning to harvest the extras yourself.

I did have a source that would harvest for me for only $5 a head or take any freebies.. ultimately I wanted cleaner carcasses and learned to do it myself plus raising heritage boys cannot be for free so giving them away was not going to be sustainable long term for me. But the main factor being.. convenience.. working with someone else's schedule and life changes happen. etc.. EVEN when I've planned ahead for all boys, people change their mind, get injured, face illness, job loss, moving, divorce, etc.. Always good to have a plan B and C... which could be your extra coop or what have you. You do YOU.

I'm too rural.. but some places even have livestock auctions where they home their extra or unwanted birds, cattle, etc. I see a few folks on here that use them regularly... NEVER buy, only sell.. for YOUR flocks' bio security!

Might not have been a fight with the head cock.. could have been an attempted mounting and a gal stood up for herself. Could have been a squabble between the two buddies even. Some folks use game cams or others in their coops to help see what might be going on.

I acknowledge that what shezadandy is stating CAN be a reality.. and the advice may be valid (even wise :thumbsup ).. I never ever clean up blood, but usually leave the body alone to work it's magic, including after having a duck scalped by a raccoon.. with a flock of 82+. The duck was stiff for several days and made a full recovery. I DO watch for flock antics though before making a decision like that.. and also continued observation.. I WILL intervene if deemed needed.. NO relentless bullies tolerated here, EVER.

When my head roo had some comb wounds, the ladies would groom the scabs daily.. making the wound heal quite slowly. The rooster invited the attention and appreciated what they were doing.. sometimes things can be itchy when healing.

A good head rooster.. is worth his weight in gold actually! Not for protection because they can't compete with most my predators and one rooster can never protect 10 hens escorting them all to and from lay boxes, etc. No wonder so many are out of balance with ALL we expect out of them! But yes for babies.. and also for ruling firmly but from a well balanced state of mind.. not over reactive and with discernment to actual threats. Once they've set the expectation they can back off instead of needing to push.

Flock dynamics are a thing of constant change.. don't expect a cockerel to know his place permanently.. chickens are ALWAYS looking to elevate their status in the flock.. higher status means first access to food, best roosting spot, choice mates, etc..

A challenge or first test.. is just that, a feeler.. does one need to get stronger and more confident before stepping up again or are they content with their place??

It's not the size of the bird in the fight .. it's the size of the fight in the bird.. at first an elder will almost always have the upper hand.. due to confidence. But with hormones and age (plus spring and summer daylight hours) comes strength and confidence plus desire to spread seed..

I've had Silkie boys put Marans and other large fowl on the run, It's kinda hilarious at times.

I enjoy chickens. I'm not claiming to have all the right answers. I KNOW especially with people and animals all being individuals.. what works with some won't work for others and maybe not even a second time. So please always use YOUR best judgement and don't get STUCK on one way only! :)

Do your kiddos have a favorite bird? :pop
Thanks for all that! I just posted a CL ad for $5 roos. They are so pretty and sweet, I hope they go soon. The kids do have favorites; the 4 we hand raised, the 2 OGs when we first started with chickens, and our alpha rooster. The bullied roo is getting it from the head roo, I saw today. Nothing major but he seems to be out for him a bit more than I have ever seen before. The blood was pretty much gone by this morning, which I was hoping would happen and I opened the coop and run and fed the 2 lesser roos some corn. Obviously everyone slept just fine last night...
 
In certain kinds of commercial or large-scale situations, yes.

That's based on having hundreds of hens, wanting all eggs to be fertile for hatching, but not wanting to have extra roosters eating feed. Basically, big hatchery conditions. And even then, it's often a bit different for different breeds--Leghorns might be 12:1 while Brahmas might be 8:1.

The fewer chickens you have, the more their individual temperaments matter. So one rooster might have 20+ hens and some have bare backs from over-mating, while another rooster might have only 2 hens and they are fine. A particular pair of roosters might get along fine, while a different pair does not.

If you intend to hatch chicks regularly, I definitely recommend you come up with a plan for future cockerels--eat them, sell them, give them away, build a big bachelor coop and keep them, build many chicken coops and purchase dozens of hens so each one gets his own flock... There are many possibilities, although some are cheaper or more convenient than others :)
If I did keep only roosters all together, wouldn't they just attack each other?
 
If I did keep only roosters all together, wouldn't they just attack each other?

I have read that a pen of ONLY roosters with no hens can be relatively peaceful (no hens to fight over, so not many fights.) I don't have much personal experience with that idea.

I did once have a pen with 7 roosters and 43 hens, and they all seemed fine. I know that breeding stock for most egg or meat chickens are kept in groups with many roosters and hundreds of hens, and they usually do fine. (How do I know they're fine? Because if the roosters killed each other, or fought so much they forgot to mate, then the hatchery would have to raise them differently in order to get fertile eggs.)
 
If I did keep only roosters all together, wouldn't they just attack each other?
Absolutely not.. it has it's challenges, but can run smoothly. I only keep a bachelor pad because I NEVER keep less than one rooster of the breed or variety I'm working with. Since I want to work with many breeds/varieties.. I (in the past) kept all roosters in one side and all hens on the other.. swap in the rooster I want to hatch from, collect only eggs of the correct color accordingly... with the rest going to eating.. This way I can keep ABOUT 3 hens of each type and have plenty of hens to have the love spread to. With all that though, even with no kiddos or 9-5 calling, it's exhausting.

My average stag pen may have up to 30 boys at any given time.. starting around 5-6 weeks, or as soon as identified as male OR booted by their broody mum.. added all at one time, spread the pecking and because they're the little's they quickly fall in line.. sometimes being taken under the wing of the head stag. It's TRUE.. more birds equal less antics.. and less birds is when individual demeanor has bigger impact.. example I like to use is like a billiards table butterfly type effect.. when one boy tries to roll it downhill.. another says oh ya, I'm above you.. and it's like the trickle down effect only upwards in the pecking order. Seems there's always someone bigger and badder. :bun

I keep mine in sight of the hens and also have one out of sight (curiosity since that what folks claim but also convenience of not moving the structure).. antics are equal regardless in MY experience.. Hens are only ONE resource to fight over.. my siblings (or adult house mates) and I squabbled plenty despite it not being about mates! Think about any boys home, I like in sight so IF I swap a boy in to hatch from, the ladies are already familiar with seeing them, they learn to treat call, serenade, etc.

Hopefully they will find a new home.. A few per year are usually lucky enough to find their own flocks here! :fl
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom