Tums for Calcium?

I'm realizing I shouldn't trust all books so readily :)
The author (and I'll have to track down what book it is later) recommended them because calcium carbonate is supposed to strengthen cell walls, therefore allowing tomatoes to deal better with a large influx of water. I don't know, sounds kinda iffy now that I think about it.
Thank you!
I suppose that IS possible...

When you say sounds iffy... I'm thinking... it's kinda like adding salt to your boiling water... claims of raising the temp to make your pasta not stick together or whatever. It is true that the salt raises the temp. BUT it is really negligible at an average of 4 degrees. Not over crowding your pan and stirring shortly after adding the pasta works quite well. We add salt only to season the pasta.

What I'm saying is... the tums thing *may* be true, but I wonder to WHAT degree? And either way... find it an interesting conversation that may lead to a deeper understanding of SOMETHING.

Now I'm curious... both sodium and calcium (bi?)cabonate are antacids (hence my initial mix up between the two)... does it have a true effect or is it irrelevant, like how they tell us something can cause cancer only to find out they dosed 5000 times the acceptable levels for an extended period of time to come up with that conclusion. In other words, I like to read studies. :p Now also... back to the tums/calcium carbonate. If it is indeed an antacid then it could very well alter the PH of your soil. Many fruits and veggies prefer acidic soil. So I wonder what effect would be the long term result. :confused:

Maybe you can do a side by side this season and do one with and 1 without tums. :pop

If you water consistently I suspect it has way less relevance. But last year my neighbor experienced quite a bit of splitting on her plums after a mid season rain storm.

Even if the soil has plenty of calcium, the plant can't uptake it in cold weather.
Also can't uptake nutrients without water. Can you elaborate to what "cold" weather is please? Thank you.
 
iNTERESTINGLY ENOUGH, MY GOOGLE SEARCHES RE: BER STATED THAT IT WAS MOST COMMONLY DUE TO RAPIDLY FLUCTUATING CHANGES IN SOIL MOISTURE LEVELS. I HAD ALWAYS BEEN UNDER THE IMPRESSION THAT BER WAS CAUSED BY SOIL BEING TOO COLD. HERE'S THE BEST ARTICLE COULD FIND THAT WAS NOT OVERLY INTELLECTUAL.

http://extension.missouri.edu/phelps/documents/Horticulture_News/BlossomEndRot.pdf

MY APOLOGY TO OP FOR HIJACK. BACK TO REGULARLY SCHEDULED PROGRAMMING.
 

Attachments

  • Nutritional Requirements of Poultry - Poultry - Merck Veterinary Manual.pdf
    57.2 KB · Views: 8
Hens lay down the eggshell in the very early morning hours, long after they would be eating any Ca supplement. Oyster shell is absorbed slowly, so it's available at that time for the hen. Rapidly metabolized Ca supplements, including finely ground egg shells, are no longer available then, so aren't as useful to the hen right when she needs them.
I'd bet that the same applies to Tums. Besides, bags of oyster shell are CHEAP, at least in the USA.
Mary
BUT my chickens dont eat the oyster shells and i have a few hens that are laying soft shell eggs
 
BUT my chickens dont eat the oyster shells and i have a few hens that are laying soft shell eggs
What I do is mix the oyster shell with scratch feed and do it a few days. Surprisingly enough they will eat the oyster shell from a separate bowl after that. Tossing it on the ground also helps.
 
BUT my chickens dont eat the oyster shells and i have a few hens that are laying soft shell eggs
Are you feeding them noting but layer feed? If so, get some human calcium citrate and give the ones that are laying softies one pill a day for 3 days.

If you're not feeding 100% layer pellets, stop feeding all other feed and feed nothing but layer feed.
 
Are you feeding them noting but layer feed? If so, get some human calcium citrate and give the ones that are laying softies one pill a day for 3 days.

If you're not feeding 100% layer pellets, stop feeding all other feed and feed nothing but layer feed.
THEY GET PURINA LAYER FEED, THEY GET SOME SCRATCH AND MEAL WORMS AS TREATS DURING THE DAY..
 
Eliminate the scratch and mealworms. Scratch is extremely low in calcium and that dilution could have originated the problem.
Scratch, depending on the types of grains, could be 0.5% calcium or less. Mealworms contain a little more than 3 mg/100 grams. That means they have virtually none.
It is important to remember that the layer feed you are giving is complete, with all the nutrients they need in exactly the right ratios. They don't need treats.
Adding scratch and mealworms will screw that up and it is best when one has the problems you do, go back to basics - meaning feed only. It is easy to underestimate the percentage of intake that treats make up. I've done that.
I refer again to the factors that affect shell quality.
https://thepoultrysite.com/articles/factors-influencing-shell-quality
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom