I totaly agree when it comes to an animal suffering, the most humane thing is to put them down. And I wasn't implying that all people in the business aspect devalue animals, but that I understand to be successful you have to seperate your emotion with logic and reason, however many of us are not in the chicken raising for the aspect of business and to us, they have more value than the aspect of what can be made off from them, and are willing to take on an animal solely so that they may live. I had to come to terms with the fact that a good share of the "unwanted" roos would become someone's supper, (sure as heck not mine), if I was going to hatch and raise chicks. I just don't want to know. I want to be left in my blind naive world where the meat I eat came from the supermarket, and didn't have a face...lolAmy, I know you were not talking to me...I am just going to state my position.
Just because I raise my birds for commercial purposes doesn't mean I devalue their lives, I probably respect them more than many people who raise them for pets.
While their lives are in my hands, they are treated humanely and if euthanizing is necessary, it's done. I had to put down my beautiful, hand raised, son of Porter's Narragansett tom, my firstborn and all time favorite turkey, by putting a pellet into his head after a dog mauled him. When my layer hens are laid out (production reds lay well for about a year and a half) I sell them. If I can find backyard chicken keepers to buy them, that has a "warm and fuzzy" feeling...yet if I sell them to someone who wants to butcher them for soup, that is also a responsible option as though their lives may be shortened, they will still be useful.
It's hard to cull a crippled chick, but sometimes it's the right thing to do. I've also gone through extreme measures trying to save birds with no chance of survival. I have kept "useless" birds around because I liked them, like a couple of six year old Ameraucana hens that were past laying, but they were the flock grandmothers and instructed many new batches of youngsters on how to use nest boxes.
I may be inconsistent, but even with my commercial poultry aspect, I still have my soft side.