Do you have any small, local chicken/homestead stores around you? I paid $30 for a 2 day old chick that is supposed to lay at least a 5 or 6 (which are the kind of eggs they have shown there, it's supposed to be a reputable little place... I'll see in a month or so). Had to drive over an hour though for a single chick.
I'd recommend something like that. I bought some from online hatcheries but I found the same thing you did right afterwards so I just sold them. Also I know people on Ebay sell hatching eggs? Some sellers are rated pretty well and show the eggs if you have any incubators.