So I've decided I'm not a huge fan of the shredded paper in the coop. The girls drag it in the nest box with them & then it sticks to the eggs. I guess not a huge deal, but it really does annoy me, ha! I did my semi annual clean of the coop last weekend & didn't put any paper in, I think I'll wet it & put it in the compost instead.
Every once in a while I get a paper shred in the nest box on an egg. It's not a big deal for me. But I don't use paper shreds in the nest boxes because I don't like paper shreds stuck on my eggs, either. I am still using pine shavings in the nest boxes.
We all live in different climates and our setups for the coops and nest boxes will be different. My nestboxes are about 1 foot off the floor and paper shreds cannot be kicked into the boxes. My girls have to jump up to the rail on the front of the nest boxes before they go in to lay an egg. I think that is maybe why so few paper shreds ever make it to my boxes.
Also, I wonder if the type of paper makes a difference. I assume it would. If we say that office paper is "normal", then newspaper shreds would be very soft and cereal box light cardboard would be hard. I mix all those papers in my coop and maybe that helps reduce the amount of paper that finds its way to the nest boxes.
Recently, since I got that pair of powered scissors for cutting heavy cardboard into strips for shredding, I have been running our box cardboard through my paper shredders as well. That packing box cardboard stuff is almost as heavy as using wood chips in the coop.
Anyways, all those different types of paper shreds get mixed together and it seems to work for me. Again, my goals are to reduce the amount of paper waste that I was sending back to the recycle center, and to increase the amount of paper products that I could use in the coop as litter and then compost later.
Out of curiosity, I am wondering what kind of paper shreds you were using and if you think your nest box setup was such that it made it easier for the girls to drag paper shreds into the boxes? I understand not wanting to have paper shreds stuck to the eggs, but it's just not something I have to deal with in my setup.
Also, what do plan on using for your coop litter after you get those paper shreds cleaned out? I have access to all the free wood chips I could ever want at our local county landfill, but this time of year I also have carts full of leaves on the ground that make good coop litter as well. I like free coop litter that is good for the compost and both wood chips and leaves have great potential in both respects.