My 3 week old chicks had shavings over newspaper. The paper was to protect the wood brooder. The chicks moved all the shavings out of the way and shredded the newspaper into tiny pieces all in one night. Next morning it was just a mess of shavings and newspaper shreds. Of course the waterer was filled with soggy newspaper too. I'd rather clean shavings out of the water than soggy newspaper. I think, when chicks get to a few weeks old, shavings or pellets is best.
