If it will make you feel better about your confusion, I hatched three BRs that are about 3 weeks old now. Dutch is obviously a boy. Then there is an obvious pullet, Zoe. The third one keeps me guessing. It's sort of in between, keeping me guessing, and I've raised these for a long time now, hatched a bunch of them. I'm going to try to get pics today when it's really hot out and I can get them in the sunshine.