What are the Best Brown Egg Layers?

The breeds you already have and the breeds you listed are all good.

The top layers over all though are Australorps, Leghorns, and Sex Links.

 

Sex links don't usually go broody, niether do Australorps. Good egg layers that have a good feed conversion aren't usually the broody type. Buff Orpingtons lay pretty good and are good mothers

 

Quote:Sexlinks would probably be your best bet. And BTW Brown Leghorns lay White eggs.

 

My Black sexlinks and Buff Orpingtons were good layers, and the BO's can tend to be broody.

 

Leghorns of any color lay white eggs.

Sex Links almost never set, but are you best layers. Just remember that sexlinks are mixed breeds and if you have chicks from them, the chicks will not match the parents.

I like australorps, but again the hatchery birds rarely set. They do have a good feed conversion rate. They are a smaller bird and do not make the best meat bird. That may not be a necessity for your future needs.

Matt

 

I had a black sex link once that never missed a day laying an egg in 3 months.

I guess I'm going to have to get a few so that I always have eggs for the table.

 

Quote:Mine were Buff Orpington x Barred Rock and I looooooooved them!!! I'm brooding out a few that are RIR over Barred Rock and Cuckoo Marans girls, so I dunno how they are gonna lay yet.

 

My 2 Australorps and 1 Buff Orpington have been great layers. They're only about a 11 months old, and I haven't seen any real 'broodiness' yet, however I believe one of my Australorps has been picking own her tummy/thigh feathers, I don't think she's molting yet, so I'm guessing that she's starting to feel kind of nesty (if that's a word). She would still rather free range all day, than sit on eggs, so I can't testify to broodiness on either of those breeds yet, but I LOVE Australorps.