It is indeed a crab apple. While I was at the hospital with my husband today, I stepped outside for a quick puff (I know, terrible habit) and was standing next to this older lady. I was looking at all the nice flowers they had when I realized the tree they had in the middle of the flower bed was my tree, just pruned different.
The lady asked me what I was looking at, because I was like, up in the tree almost, lol, and I told her the story. Her family used to have a nursery, long story short, she identified it as a crabapple, and said we shouldn't eat the berries.
Thanks for everyone's help. Isn't it strange how answers often come from the most unexpected places?
Thanks again!
Jess