- Jul 24, 2013
- 20,586
- 1,382
- 401
Welcome to BYC!
I'm glad you joined our community.
I would personally pick the Wyandottes. Mine have been good egg layers (over 250 eggs in their first year), very hardy through cold and heat, and have had the most docile, personable, and inquisitive temperaments of all my chickens. Mine have not gone broody, but they are hatchery birds. Hatchery birds in general do not go broody as often as those you would get from a breeder, because hatcheries breed for high egg production (and broody birds don't lay well).
I do not have any personal experience with New Hampshires. However, I will say that they will likely have similar temperaments and egg production to your Rhode Island Reds, unless you get from a breeder. Most hatchery "red" birds, be they Rhode Island Reds, New Hampshires, or Red Sex-Links often have similar characteristics, since hatcheries tend to intermix them to create a high production strain.

I would personally pick the Wyandottes. Mine have been good egg layers (over 250 eggs in their first year), very hardy through cold and heat, and have had the most docile, personable, and inquisitive temperaments of all my chickens. Mine have not gone broody, but they are hatchery birds. Hatchery birds in general do not go broody as often as those you would get from a breeder, because hatcheries breed for high egg production (and broody birds don't lay well).
I do not have any personal experience with New Hampshires. However, I will say that they will likely have similar temperaments and egg production to your Rhode Island Reds, unless you get from a breeder. Most hatchery "red" birds, be they Rhode Island Reds, New Hampshires, or Red Sex-Links often have similar characteristics, since hatcheries tend to intermix them to create a high production strain.