What could she need?

[mertzee]

Membrane and thin shell. It’s just rolled for some reason?? I have Denegard and Tylan 200 on hand, would suggest one or the other?

 

[azygous]

Use the Denegard.

 

[mertzee]

This is so frustrating! Caught one of my other hens peck at this this morning. Membrane only. No shell at all. I got some calcium and have crushed it up and gonna give it to her in some mash or something she will eat. What gives?

 

[aart]

This is so frustrating!

It is, BTDT.
Some birds are just 'lemons'.

 

[BDutch]

Laying soft eggs isn’t always a lack of calcium. If the other hens all lay normal eggs it’s probably something else. It may need time to heal.
Just give proper feed, calcium on the side, wait and see. Sometimes problems like that are suddenly over after a molt.

 

[mertzee]

Good news is she has resumed laying small chocolate brown eggs!!

 

[BDutch]

Good news is she has resumed laying small chocolate brown eggs!!

I love chocolate eggs. or any other chocolates. Just kidding

Good news. Congrats