When I first started canning, my Mom told me to always bring a small pot of water to a boil. Remove from heat and drop in my lids to pre-warm the rubber seal when I was ready to fill my jars. She said as long as she preheated those lids she hardly ever had one not seal. So this is what I've always done to any brand lid I use. I rarely have an issue.
Just this year, I've used Ball and Golden Harvest and have more of each in my kitchen. I hope they are good.
Might be something to try. I hate to do all that work and something go wrong.
Those blue lids you have do look like that have more sealing surface. That's got to be better.