We don't give a hoot what's in style, fortunately, and we're not selling, ever. This is our last home, our forever home. Any changes or improvements are going to be whatever we like. Resale value? Ability to get the cost back out of it? Don't care, doesn't matter to us.
That's very freeing, actually. As for the cost, we have been budgeting for projects like this for years. We couldn't have done it 15-20 years ago. Now we're in a position to do them.
The selling point of this house is the land it's on and the location. It's a small market -- out in the middle of nowhere, on a dead end road with 1/4 mile driveway that the county doesn't maintain. For many people, that is a no-go right there. For the people who live back here, it's a BIG plus. Zero traffic. Very quiet.
And room for two big gardens, plus chickens, including roosters.