I have 2 chest freezers and a standup. My smallest chest freezer is half the size of the upright, but will hold everything in the upright, and still have room. If you want storage, go with a chest. If you want energy savings, go with a chest. My upright does that self defrost thing so I never get ice buildup like in the chest freezers, but it costs about double to run. Uprights cost more to purchase per square foot and hold less, but sometimes it's nice to be able to find stuff without having to empty half your freezer! (laundry baskets work wonders for that, though!) . Hope this help! Karla