froggiesheins, the bottom line is that all horses are just not trained alike. And so they can't be handled the same way by the next owner or the next handler.
That one where he or Linda Peperoni were getting after the British show jumper's horse who wouldn't let him bridle him - we laughed our tails off at that one. I could barely keep from peeing myself. Talk about making a mess of something. I can just imagine the Brothers Whittaker, going through the barn and settling on which horse to send him to do the demo on LOL!
We ran into a guy once, who handled horses like parelli and he came up to our barn to pick up an event horse, a great big warmblood about 4 yrs old and hot as a two dollar pistol and twice as fit.
Now of course I had someone else egging me on, a smarty pants seventeen year old rich kid, pa was some diplomat or something so that kid knew no fear, I should have tackled her at the start.
But this guy couldn't get this filly into his trailer. Well the horse would get part way on and then come tearing out a hundred miles an hour, bashing its head and slamming into the trailer and everything. This happened, oh, fifty or sixty times. The horse was getting out of its mind, the guy was getting mad and starting to take it out on the horse by time TWO.
Well, I'm senile and I can't remember all of it, it was long ago, but basically, the teenager yelled out, 'I think the problem is you're giving her too much practice in gettin' OFF the trailer. She needs to practice gettin' ON'. Then the kid walked over and loaded the horse. Stood there in there in the trailer for a while, then backed her off, did her about SIX times.
Then takes the horse out, walks over to the guy, hands him the lead rope and says, 'See, she needed practice getting ON, not OFF'. All the funny images aside this was about working a horse a way it knows, instead of trying to change it instantly to some other way.
Come to think of it, I was right in there helpin' and goin' 'yup! yup!' when she said that. The only thing I disagreed on was, let's leave after we put the horse IN the trailer, not after we take it out.
People just have to work with the horse, with what it knows, and how it's been worked with. It's not going to instantly change.