m.kitchengirl :
I have struggled with this all along. I switched from shavings to hay (found out I am EXTREMELY allergic to hay
) switched to the chunkier pine shavings. I have switched back to hay again.
I think it is really personal.
I can only speak for myself, but those pine shavings drive me BONKERS
. They get everywhere. No matter what I do.
Not copious amounts mind, but there are STRAYS, stragglers. No matter how careful I am.
It makes me want to sit there, right next to the Quack Shack, and pick them up from around the door.
.
So, I may get hives and itchy eyes, and have some trouble breathing when I handle hay, but I prefer it to those darn shavings.
I can rake the icky parts out each day & right into the garden, or compost, after some "airing out" time.
It doesn't leave a trail, or a flake. It goes where it belongs.
Like I said, I think it is a matter of personal preference. I acknowledge that my "logic" is flawed on this subject.
X2 I use straw though... My ancona hen likes to make my life hard though... She likes to play with it though! She grab some in her mouth and runs away, and scratches it all out nomatter what I do to stop her! Then I have to kick it back in all the time! Shes insane! But I love those cute little nests she builds when she lays a egg
I deal with it though... if they could go without it I wouldnt put any in, but thqt is cruel to not put straw in to cuddle up to...