What the heck is Charlie?

[starfishthreads]

Hey all,
My mom and I are new to chickens. We purchased chicks from a lady that hatches eggs she nuys on ebay. They were all supposed to be silkies, but Charlie is definitely not a silkie. I just uploaded a photo of him with the others (I circled Charlie in red). Does anybody have any idea what s/he might be?
Thanks so much,
Krista

 

[Indigosands]

probably a rhode island red. If it's a she, she will lay really nice big brown eggs.

 

[chickenreferee]

A production red?

 

[chickenmaniac]

what color are the legs? if they are green then a easter egger, if not it looks like a russian orloff because of the puffy cheeks

 

[starfishthreads]

His legs are orange

 

[chickenmaniac]

well then yess i believe a russian orloff, that was a great buy either way because russian orloffs are rare

 

[chickenmaniac]

i have one myself shes a pullet and looked like that when she was younger

 

[starfishthreads]

Thanks everyone, I can't wait to see what s/he turns into!

 

[starfishthreads]

Hello everyone,
I uploaded some updated photos of Charlie. I got so many different answers, I thought I would try again now that Charlie is looking more "chickeny". I think one of the reds (production, rhode island, etc.) What do the experts think?