M
Member 482121
Guest
I admit, I'm a wimp. Anything that lives must kill other things... but the thought of causing needless stress or harm makes me sick to my stomach. Dying (in a way that allows the organism to be used within the food chain) is never easy or painless... but I'm really stuck between the two most prevalent methods here (decapitation vs bleeding).
I've seen cut/bleeding birds caw and draw away. It just doesn't look humane. It looks very painful. Excessively, so.
Yet, I also agree that we have no idea how "alive," something is after decapitation. It could be far worse.
I've been poking around this thread but I haven't seen it; does anyone know of any studies on one versus the other in terms of neurological function/time of death? It seems I have a cornish x chick, so I'm trying to look into this stuff now rather than in 6-7 weeks when it'll be too late.
It's not a pleasant topic, I know, but... they're giving their lives for me and my belief is that I owe them, at the very least, the most painless out possible. I just don't know what to do. Maybe there is no right or wrong answer. Maybe it's equal. But I thought if any community/group of people could help me, it would be BYC.
Well, I have recently read the conclusions of studies conducted on decapitated rats. There have also been some reports on decapitated people (before the guillotine was abolished as a cruel means of executing criminals) by doctors/researchers who observed executions. All these studies and observations seem to show that death does not come immediately as the head is severed, but only after at least 30 seconds and at times up to 60 seconds after decapitation. I assume that those 30-60 seconds while the brain is still alive must be horrible. Someone here pointed out that when snakes are beheaded their heads remain alive and conscious for more time than that, as they can perceive the presence of an object in front of their face and try to bite it. And, the poster wrote, considering that birds are quite similar to their reptilian ancestors, chickens' heads may remain "alive" and conscious for a longish time. Look, ultimately death is death and almost always painful. If others do believe that beheading their chickens or cutting their throat is humane, then let them do it that way. But I have beheaded chickens in the past and I have seen their eyes blink and their beaks open and close in what I thought was an expression of intense pain and terror. So, when it comes to MY chickens, who trust me, follow me around, and (some of them) come close to me to be petted, I can't bear the thought of making them feel that pain and that terror. That's why my wife and I first pet the chickens until they are calm and relaxed, and then hold them over a large planter filled with dirt. And I shoot them in the back of the head with a .22 pistol. I do it safely, of course. Their cranium literally explodes. The brain, the "receiver" and "interpreter" of physical pain is instantly destroyed. There is no chance of pain or terror. I understand that not everyone will or can do it this way. But it is MY way, and I know deep in my heart and my brain that that is the best possible way for MY chickens to be transformed into the food that keeps us alive. Yet I still dread the arrival of the day when I will have to do this. I enjoy hunting, but I did not raise the wild animals that I kill, they do not trust me, and they are not held prisoners in a pen from which they can't escape. There is quite a difference. But I don't feel joy at the death of my prey. I do apologize to each animal that I kill and honor them by making sure that every morsel of their flesh becomes our sustenance--without any waste. And in a way they become part of me and I part of them when I absorb their vital flesh in my body--as God (or Nature for non-believers) has planned eons ago for all animals and plants when He decreed that the life of one being is based on the death of others.