What I've had thus far over the years or have in my flock now:
RIR, RSL/GSL, BSL, Brown Leghorn, Barred Rock, White Leghorn, Delaware, New Hampshire, Buff Orpington, Wyandotte, Rhodebar, Buckeye, Black Copper Marans, Welsummer, Easter Egger, Silkie, Bantam Cochin, game mixes
What I'm growing out now (almost to point of lay):
California Grey, Olive Egger (Isbar/Marans)
What I've got in brooding (chicks):
GSL, Barnevelder, Isbar
What I want yet:
Australorps, so I can say I've tried them
Black Langshan
Cream Crested Legbar
Penedesenca (if I can ever learn how to spell them)
true Ameraucana (not EE's)
What am I looking for?
Half the flock in the perfect all around bird that lays well with the unwanted rooster(s) coming to table nicely before crowing too much (neighbors)...Rhodebars actually did well for that overall and add the ease of autosexing. However, eggs still are medium to large their first laying year, which is smaller than I hoped, but they lay well.
Buckeyes were much better size, roo's coming to table nicely before they really got noisy, but the hens are only okay layers, and no auto-sexing, but the hens will make nice stewers upon retirement as they are big girls.
Then half the flock in specialty color egg types...the dark browns, greens, blues, olives, and yes, even purple if I can get there.
What breeds would I get again?
RSL/GSL (great layers, I try to keep half my flock in them until I find the "perfect" go to breed as they lay well with rich color)
BSL, nice steady layer and all that I've had have been sweet
Silkie, best brooders
Rhodebars, would like to see if I can get improved birds that lay really well with larger egg size and still with nice rooster size and good autosexing...had to eat my one rooster as he was unfortunately wheaten and not good for breeding autosexing
Buckeyes if I can bump laying as meal size is excellent, but hard to find in my area and slower than meat birds for the grain you pump in them if they don't lay well
What breeds were disappointments?
Wyandottes, Delawares, Buff Orpingtons...ate way more than they produced, espeically the Buff Orps
Welsummers, good layers of nice darker eggs, but noisy, flighty, and broody (at least what I got), but may try again with another line
Barred Rocks, decent layers but chickens get too nosy...just have their beak in everything including my pant legs, annoying
Easter Eggers...egg quality was always poorer (on same feed/grit/care as everyone else)
What breeds would not get again
RIR...noisy, aggressive...seriously...gave them to my daughter and they are known as the loudest chickens in the county...and that's in farmland folks
LofMc