which to keep?

Discussion in 'Managing Your Flock' started by Love4zion, Jun 25, 2016.

  1. Love4zion

    Love4zion Out Of The Brooder

    I bought 8 chicks and they are around 12 weeks old now. Our Andalusian ended up being a roo. He's been crowing for a week. We also think one of our SLW is a roo. We didn't want keep both because we don't want to burden our hens. The main question is , which would be the better one to keep? [​IMG][​IMG] or do you think the SLW is a pullet
  2. Ravynscroft

    Ravynscroft For the Love of Duck Premium Member

    Nov 30, 2014
    Middle Tennessee
    Keep the one with the best temperament...
  3. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner True BYC Addict

    Feb 2, 2009
    Northwest Arkansas
    With the tail feathers curling down and with those hackle feathers that SLW looks like a male. Sorry.

    Why do you want a rooster? What are your goals? If you plan on hatching chicks, what do you want the offspring to look like and act like? Even behaviors are influenced by genetics. You need to make this decision yourself, which male best suits your unique situation. With my goals I’d eat the smaller and breed the larger but my goals aren’t your goals.
  4. Love4zion

    Love4zion Out Of The Brooder

    thanks for the reply. I never intended on getting a rooster but since we let let them free range we thought we would keep 1 for flock protection. Do you have an opinion on me light Brahma? I hope I done have anymore boys?[​IMG][​IMG]
  5. bobbi-j

    bobbi-j Flock Master

    Mar 15, 2010
    On the MN prairie.
    Having a rooster in your flock doesn't guarantee flock protection. They are more of an alarm system than anything, and a dominant hen can take on that role if there is no rooster in the flock. Often times, a rooster is just a speed bump - slowing the predators down by being killed first, before the predator gets the hens. We lost a rooster and several hens to coyotes a few years ago. If you don't want a rooster, I'd say don't keep either of them.
  6. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner True BYC Addict

    Feb 2, 2009
    Northwest Arkansas
    The Brahma looks like a pullet to me. Mainly that is the rounded hackle feathers and the look of the tail. General body shape looks more pullet than cockerel to me. I think you are OK.

    I suggest people keep as few roosters as they can and still meet their goals. That does not mean you are guaranteed more problems with more roosters, just that problems are more likely the more roosters you have. I don’t know what the right number is for you but I suspect it is either zero or one. I know people get attached to their chickens as pets. Cockerels are often the favorites because they usually have more personality. Even at a very young age they are often braver and more curious. The longer you keep them the harder it may be to get rid of one. Still you might try one and get rid of it if you run into problems.

    I pretty much agree with Bobbi, a rooster doesn’t offer a huge amount of protection. Some will take on certain predators like hawks, that does sometimes happen, but mine tend to lead the flock to safety once a threat has been identified instead of placing himself between the threat and his flock. Before a threat is clearly identified but when something suspicious is going on, a good rooster will place himself between the flock and the threat and maybe even go check it out. There is some benefit to that, but I believe the amount of protection you actually get is pretty overrated. Not all roosters are good. Twice I’ve had dog attacks that left 8 and 5 chickens dead. Both times the rooster was not scratched.
  7. Love4zion

    Love4zion Out Of The Brooder

    an alarm system for the hens is what i need. Our coop is right outside our side/back door. Hawks and crows are probably my biggest threat.
  8. aart

    aart Chicken Juggler! Premium Member

    Nov 27, 2012
    SW Michigan
    My Coop
  9. oldhenlikesdogs

    oldhenlikesdogs Shazam Premium Member

    Jul 16, 2015
    central Wisconsin
    I have had crows take chicks, so I don't want them hanging around either. I like my roosters, they are always keeping watch,and they will sacrifice themselves often going after the predators.

    I would wait as long as possible before making your choice. If one is making trouble pen him up and see how the other does in his place. Those that mature quickly and are vigorous at mating will often not be as good as a look out in my experience. It can take up to year for roosters to mature enough to calm down and do a good job.
  10. Love4zion

    Love4zion Out Of The Brooder

    Thanks for the replies.!!

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by