Who to Keep and Who to Sell?

3KillerBs

Addict
16 Years
Educator Spirit Friend
Joined
Jul 10, 2009
Messages
23,957
Reaction score
73,696
Points
1,471
Location
North Carolina Sandhills
My Coop
My Coop
I have 7 pullets of 15 and 17 weeks in a coop intended for 4 and with our house already over 2 months behind schedule the larger facility will not be in place for winter. Therefore I have to sell at least 2 of them.

I have one California White. I'm keeping her to have a white layer.

1602431927092.png


I have two Blue Australorps, who are the absolute picture of vigor and good health. I can't tell them apart now that Cordon dropped her white wingtip feathers in this most recent juvenile molt. They're both active, alert, beautifully-made (DH described their looks as "What you think of when you say "chicken"), and obviously maturing. I'm willing to push to 5 in the coop if there's no trouble given the huge pen made by the 100 feet of electric poultry net and the prospect of a new coop by spring so I'm planning to keep both if there is no sign of over-crowding issues. These photos, taken a week apart, could be both of them or one of them twice. I absolutely can't tell.

1602432335418.png


1602432446243.png


I have two Light Brahmas. One of them, Omelet, was bigger as a chick and got red-faced early but has not developed any rooster characteristics and is now smaller than her sister, Dumpling. And I am sure I'm not mixing them up because Omelet has always had more dark feathers on her back than Dumpling. I'm thinking that I'll keep Dumpling because a Brahma ought to be large and because, in my inexpert opinion, she seems to better approach the Brahma SOP in her hatchery-quality way.

Dumpling on the left, Omelet on the right (note the darkness on her back).
1602433032185.png


It's hard to get good comparison pictures because if they are not side-by-side the size difference is not obvious and the camera tends to wash out Omelet's redder face.

Finally, I have two Silver-Laced Wyandottes. Picatta is a little larger, has a pink face, and has bad lacing on her shoulders that made me suspect that she could be a cockerel when she was younger. Popcorn is a little smaller, has a purple face, and has better lacing. My initial instinct is to keep Popcorn with her prettier coloring but I am a little uncertain because she is my smallest bird and seems to be lowest in the pecking order. (She and Chipotle are my escape artists -- Chipotle goes over fences, Popcorn goes under them). That's Popcorn on the blocks to the right of the Brahmas above.

Picatta (pardon her lack of tail features -- juvenile molt in progress):
1602433811964.png



Picatta in front, Popcorn in back.
1602434381692.png


Popcorn between the Dumpling on the right and Omelet on the left, Picatta preening.
1602434215073.png


All of them seem to be in excellent health. None of them have any bad behavior habits like feather picking or bullying. None of them have any particularly distinctive personality traits except for Chipotle's boldness.

I like them all. But I don't have the space and the relative who was going to choose two or three to add to her flock backed out.

Thoughts?
 
They are all gorgeous. Keep you or your family members favorites. I am sure it is a difficult decision, but agree with sourland, you can't go wrong!:)
 
Beautiful birds - you can't go wrong regardless of choice.
They are all gorgeous. Keep you or your family members favorites. I am sure it is a difficult decision, but agree with sourland, you can't go wrong!

From Welp via Carolina Town and Country in Sanford, NC.

I'm quite happy with them all and can sell with a completely clear conscience that I would not be passing on problems to someone else to cope with.
 
I feel your pain.
I was raising 13 in enough room for ten. Wife’s uncle needs to renew his flock, so I shoved 12 under my broody.
Next Saturday all but my broody 8 of the chicks shoved under her, are going to their new home.
 
If it doesn't matter to you (beyond the ones you do want), why not let the buyer choose which they want.

Because if there are reasons to keep one Brahma rather than the other or one Wyandotte rather than the other that I'm too inexperienced to spot I want to keep the best. :)

Ideally I'd keep the first to lay, but I know that two of them are sleeping on the floor because the roost is full and that I'd be chiding someone who had 7 adult birds in a 16 square foot coop so I'm already past the optimum time to reduce the flock.

But it's only in the last couple weeks with this final juvenile molt that I've been reasonably confident that Picatta and Omelet are pullets rather than cockerels.
 
I was raising 13 in enough room for ten. Wife’s uncle needs to renew his flock, so I shoved 12 under my broody.
Next Saturday all but my broody 8 of the chicks shoved under her, are going to their new home.

That was what was supposed to happen to my extras. My daughter's MIL was going to take them. But she's now caring for her mother during an illness and can't expand her flock right now. :(
 
Personally the Brahmas would be the first to go. Tight coop will be easier with smaller chickens.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom