Who's gotten high hatch rates on shipped eggs, and...?

Quote:
I'm not assuming any one cause of poor hatches.
Since the hatch rate with my own eggs is very high, and my hatch rate with shipped eggs has been very low, I think that that means either A) The eggs were damaged in shipping, or B) the eggs were duds to begin with, or possibly, in the case of developing, but dying part way through incubation, or even just before or during hatch, it could be C) lethal gene reinforcement causing a high mortality rate, or D) poor health of breeding stock. Or some other factor I haven't thought of.

If a seller has less than 50% hatch rate, on average, and another seller of the same breed has 75-99% successful hatch rate, guess who's eggs I'd rather buy? Even if I end up with only 10%, that's ten% better than I've gotten on 4 out of 5 shipments.

If I only buy from people with a high hatch rate in the eggs they sell and ship, I think it would improve the odds of getting a good hatch. If I buy from sellers whose eggs often don't hatch, I think that would just continue my throwing away money on eggs to put in my incubator for 3 weeks and then watch them not hatch.

The 3 breeds I'm trying to get shouldn't be all that hard to hatch. They aren't really hard-to-hatch breeds. As far as I know, anyway.

We all tend to look at what goes on with our own birds, and expect similar conditions with other people's birds. We let our own experience color our expectations. It doesn't always work out that way, though.
 
Quote:
I completely agree. Once the eggs hit the incubator, the conditions there will definitely have an impact on hatching. The proof of the pudding when it comes to hatching eggs is how many candle fertile at 7 to 10 days (and even then, it's not always the breeder's fault, as no one can control the way the box is handled once they've shipped it!) Any time I send a box of eggs out, I am reminded of that commercial with the gorillas and the suitcase:
(no offense meant to anyone who works for the USPS!)
 
hey I am new at this until i found BYC i thought i could only get my eggs from ebay i had my last 2 good hatches from ebay 1 being giant cochins BBS from (Bluewaterranch) out of texas 66% and the other light brahmas not bantam from (Chesserfarms70)out of kentucky 70% hatch rate very pleased,my next hatch is from a BYC'r Pamspride due the 13th jersey giants out of ohio hope that helps.
 
I'm not saying a low hatch rate is the breeder's fault, I'm saying there are too many variables to pin it down. But if I go with eggs from a source with a higher hatch rate, on average, I think my odds are better. It could be that the seller's local PO is more careful, and they don't start getting tossed around until later in the trip. Or something I've never thought of.

And I think they're much better if I can keep the eggs out of the hands of the PO altogether.

I picked up eggs from a Brahma breeder a few years back, and he said fertility was only about 50%, but I hatched something like 20 out of 24. Had they been shipped, who knows? Maybe the same, maybe none!

I'm not trying to assign blame here for anything, I'm just wanting to improve the odds, that's all.
 
Last edited:

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom