Who's my Dad?

[Chickstarrs]

I would like to figure out who the parents are of this young roo. He hatched from a pinkish egg on Sept 15. He may have had one long tail feather and lost it or I may be thinking of my other young roo who definitely has a long tail feather. The possible parents are pictured below. I am wondering if he might be carrying a coloured egg gene.
Thanks so much for any help.

Mom 1 Shirley

Mom 2 Henrietta

Dad 1 Chicken Joe has never had a tail

Dad 2 Winston

 

[Coops Dad]

I'm betting it's Henrietta and Joe.

 

[JacinLarkwell]

@nicalandia

 

[RubelliteRose]

It looks like he has a little bit of a muff and crest, so I think Winston is Dad as I don't see a muff on either mom. His coloring is a lot like my boy Ron whose mom is a silver leghorn, so I'm going with Henrietta for mom That is a total guess though.

 

[Coops Dad]

These two. IDK their names anymore.

 

[Chicken poppy]

I vote Henrietta as mom and Joe for the dad.

 

[Amer]

Unrelated to our discussion but Winston is absolutely gorgeous. The red and black are just so perfect and lustrous.

 

[Chickstarrs]

These two. IDK their names anymore.View attachment 3378638View attachment 3378639

Henrietta and Chicken Joe

 

[Chickstarrs]

Seems to be most votes are for Joe and Henrietta. They did spend a lot of time together. But the young cockerel has a tuft and muffs. Neither Joe or Henrietta did whereas Winston had both and a beard. Are tuffs and muffs recessive that they would show up in a second generation? Here's another picture of Henrietta.

 

[nicalandia]

I am sure 100% That Winston it's his sire. and Henrietta his Dame.