Prince is beautiful!

I say let the hens choose, but have the reserve of a Mama's eye...and they will likely prefer the roo that pampers them and protects them alike. Even if they seem to be going along with the less-nice roo, they may do that to not get beat up or cause fights, so don't be afraid to rehome if one of the roos is too aggressive. They will go to the nicer roo once the other leaves, regardless! If Prince comes to their rescue and tidbits for them ("tidbitting' is that sweet behavior you saw, where he finds something yummy then calls the hens over to eat it) and looks out for them, he is already proving himself to be a very good "hubby/daddy figure."