HollowOfWisps
Previously AstroDuck
I would go with #1 then for three reasons:I haven’t asked about testing with this particular breeder, but I’ve bought from her before and seemed legit and all good. She told me she started with greenfire farms bloodline also but over the years introduced other marans bloodline to make the eggs darker.
1. The other two roosters look a little lanky compared to 1. Maran roosters should be a little more compact.
2. You have already purchased from her
3. One rooster is easier to deal with than two.