When I was in your shoes, I picked Brahmas.
"The King of all Poultry"
1. They are beautiful, large, majestic birds.
2. They lay lots of eggs.
3. If I needed meat...again; Large.
4. Gentle, not bullies, yet tough when challenged.
I like their lineage....A bit mysterious, but through research I found that they likely have Malay blood in them.
Which makes sense to me, considering their tall stance, and menacing; "Beetle Brow"
The choice will be easier to dial in on, if the wants and needs of the keeper are defined.
Let us know what your situation is.
ie. location, flock size, food, fun, hobby, money, etc.
Though I picked Brahmas, my Grand Daughters pulled a fast one on me, and so did the breeder I purchased from
1. Grand Daughters brought home two Buff Orpington hens.
2. The breeder picked out a male Light Brahma for me, that ended up being a White Sultan!
I knew it wasn't right,(color pattern) but she convinced me the unusual look of the chick, was due to it being a male, compared to all the females.
I now have a White Sultan Rooster I need to find a home for.
(He's crowing!) OMG!....after just writing this, he started going off! (2:45 PM)
Mental telepathy?
Good Luck!