Nest Boxes; why do we make a sitting hens job so difficult?

By Shadrach · Sep 25, 2018 · ·
  1. Shadrach
    Hens have been laying eggs, sitting on them and and hatching them for centuries without human interference. Considering their ancestors the jungle fowl still manage to maintain a reasonably healthy species population despite the hens nesting on the jungle floor where they may stay for twenty four days or more while they wait for their young to be sufficiently mobile to roost in the trees with the rest of their group.

    Until comparatively recently the domesticated chicken has survived in rural villages, farms, smallholdings and estates all over the world with the minimum of human intervention and without coops and without custom built nest boxes.

    The availability of coops and nesting boxes has meant the modern hen has learnt to adapt to new nesting environments in an incredibly short period of time and this I would argue is a testimony to the intelligence of the species in general.

    I became interested in what makes the ideal nesting site having had many hens over the past seven years, make nests in various places away from their coops. I could find no common factor in seclusion, height (I had one hen make a nest in the top of a rotting palm tree stump) material or degree of protection.
    The only common factor I could find with all the various sites was, in each site the hen had been able to make a basket with the site material and these baskets all had an indentation in the base of the nest in which the hens laid the eggs.

    The nesting behaviour of every hen I have observed, with, or without, a roosters assistance has been the same. The hen chooses a site and then scratches the ground. If there is loose material such as straw, wood shavings, cut grass, e.t.c. this material is scratched to the perimeter, or sometimes completely away in the case of a nest box with an open front and the hen settles on the base material. Once the hen has laid her clutch she positions herself in a manner that enables her to cover the maximum number of eggs. This way she can control the temperature and humidity of her eggs with maximum efficiency. During the next 18 days the hen will turn her eggs at regular intervals.

    The ability of the hen to turn her egg in these 18 days helps to prevent development deformities. For the last three days of incubation the hen must keep the eggs in a particular orientation to facilitate hatching. The overall success of egg hatching is attributed to the hens ability to turn the eggs in the first few days of incubation.

    Most chicken keepers make their nesting boxes with the same material as they use for egg boxes; wood, metal, or plastic. Often these boxes are partially filled with loose bedding material such as straw. It is not possible for a hen to scratch out a hollow in the bases of these boxes and she must rely solely on her ability to manoeuvrer her eggs into the optimal position.

    Here is an entertaining challenge for the reader. Place a dozen eggs in such a box. Mark one side of each egg and see if you can turn all the eggs so the mark is facing upward using the palm of your hand and one finger to represent a hens beak.

    I first noticed the impossibility of this task with a young hen called Cheepy ( a very small bantam) a number of years ago.
    Cheepy was rescued from a nest she had made on an exposed bank and put in the isolation coop with a dozen of the twenty something eggs she had accumulated. The isolation unit has a removable plywood floor. Plenty of straw was provided and I used to sit and watch cheepy sitting for many hours over the incubation period. Cheepy’s frustration at trying to control the position of her eggs was evident. No sooner had she pulled couple under her when another couple would roll out to the edge of the straw nest.
    I took the plywood floor out after a couple of days of watching this and cheepy immediately dug a hollow in the now exposed earth into which she rolled the eggs. She could now sit on top of the eggs and turn them without them rolling away from under her and arrange the straw around her to help maintain humidity and warmth. She hatched 10 of the 12 and checking later the two unhatched weren’t fertilized.

    A much happier Cheepy sitting on 12 eggs on an earth floor in the isolation coop.
    I'm busy. Go away whoever you are. (Large).JPG

    I’ve watched the much larger Maran and Maran bantam crosses have similar problems controlling eggs during sitting on man made nest bases. On hard surfaces the Marans in particular seemed to have great difficulty in supporting their weight in a position that allowed them to sit on top of the eggs and they arranged the eggs around their bodies and under their wings, their legs tended to splay outwards because their feet were unable to find a grip on the flooring. This wouldn’t be a problem in the comparatively short time it takes to lay an egg but prolonged periods of time in such a position resulted in two hens having tendon strain due to splayed legs.

    In the last three days of incubation the hen communicates with the embryos and the embryos with each other. These communications allow the hen to assess the development rate of the clutch and by adjusting the position of herself relative to the eggs slow down, or speed up the embryos development, thereby ensuring that the embryos hatch within a time frame that permits the maximum number of hatchings before she has to leave the nest with her chicks to find food and water; usually 24 hours. This also means that all the chicks that hatch develop at approximately the same rate and the situation I have encountered here where there may be a 36 to 48 hour gap between hatchings is avoided and all the chicks have a relatively equal size and development state which maximises all the chicks chances of survival in competing for resources as they develop.

    Many chicken keepers make broody boxes which are placed inside the coop and often separated from the rest of the coop in some fashion. This can compound the problems already mentioned.
    In order to successfully incubate eggs the hen not only has to control temperature but also humidity.
    Chickens do not have sweat glands so they cannot impart moisture to the eggs environment through sweating; they are reliant to a greater or lesser degree on atmospheric conditions. In dry climates in particular in such sheltered arrangements this can be problematical. In a natural setting i.e. outside on the ground, there is in all but the most extreme environments some dew fall that moistens the ground and the hens body heat will convert this into vapour helping to maintain humidity levels in the site locality.

    There is one final problem with the interior closed broody coop and that is in a ‘natural’ setting a hen will leave the egg clutch at some point each day to feed, drink and defecate, but equally important, dust bath.
    The importance of dust bathing and having the opportunity to defecate away from the nest site for broody hens cannot be emphasised enough. It helps the hen keep her nest site free of parasites and clean of droppings which attract further parasites. Many of the hens I’ve observed have preferred slightly damp soil for dust bathing while sitting on eggs. While this is conjecture it seems possible that the hen moistens her plumage in such baths and this helps with maintain humidity when she returns to the nest site.

    With the above in mind and my experience with Cheepy I decided to experiment with a different nest box arrangement using the same isolation coop that Cheepy hatched her 10 chicks in.

    The most obvious course was to simply remove the plywood base of the isolation coop leaving bare earth underneath. However, this left a coop security problem. It would be relatively easy for a ground predator to dig underneath the coop.
    I wanted the coop to be moveable so the next most obvious solution; make a security skirt around the outer edges of the entire coop dug a few inches into the ground wasn’t an option.

    I stapled a mesh to the underside of the coop next and filled the bottom two or three inches with plain earth. The hens seemed interested in this arrangement but the earth quickly dried out and with the ground scratching of both roosters and hens when making a nest and the mesh below became exposed. While having exposed mesh didn’t pose much of a problem for the hens, if chicks were hatched over the exposed mesh there seemed to be a risk that the chicks toes could get caught in the holes.

    Isolation coop showing mesh base.
    P9251139 (Large).JPG

    During my research for the book I’m writing I made contact with someone in Finland who also uses a multi coop arrangement for his chickens. He keeps a relatively rare Finnish breed of chicken which he is trying to preserve and re-populate. He had found similar problems with nest boxes and he is particularly interested in maximising the clutch hatchings from his sitting hens. He found that a large clod of soil cut from a semi bog environment which grew lichens and the small roosted plants made an excellent nest box base. The plant root system helped hold the soil together and thus helped preserve the hollow his hens scratched out when making nests. He also suggested spraying the hen and soil with a plant mister once a day to help maintain the moisture content of the nest base.

    The climate where I live is dry and it took me some time to find a suitable patch of ground from which I could dig a section of turf which has well enough established plant roots system to hold the soil together when the hens scratched a hollow.

    Next I had to wait for a suitable hen to go broody and sit, preferably one that had used the nest box in my house. The hens that have used this nest box in the past have been transferred to the isolation coop on day 17 so that when the chicks hatch they have immediate access to natural ground, the coop being at ground level. This allows the mother to take the chicks in and out of the coop at will.

    This year such an opportunity arose and I cut a turf which had long grass growing on it. I cut it about 4 inches thick and at the dimensions of the coop floor plan and placed it in the coop on top of the wire base. I also made a hollow in the soil and on top of this a placed a layer of straw in which I carefully placed the hens eggs in as near to an identical arrangement as they had in the nest box.

    In the past when hens have used the nest box in my house it had taken a few ‘placings’ of the hen to get her to accept that the coop is where she should sit. The hens tend to leave the coop and return to the nest box in the house, despite there being no eggs in the box.
    For this particular hen it took two attempts before she settled. She had 4 eggs which while she sat in the house nest box had been spread around her body under her wings. In the nest in the isolation coop she sat with the eggs underneath her breast, her feet gaining ground purchase on the outer edges of the hollow. She hatched all four eggs within 12 hours, one chick didn’t survive.

    Given I’ve watched over twenty hens sit and hatch chicks in a variety of circumstances here now and what I’ve learnt through the experiences of others I have made contact with over the last seven years who also keep chickens I’m left with little doubt that the ability of the hen to control the orientation, temperature and humidity of her eggs is vital to maximise clutch hatching success. I’m also left with little doubt that the ‘modern’ nest boxes made with solid floors is far from ideal. Such nest boxes are constructed for the convenience of the keeper and are liable to give rise to many of the problems outlined above.

    Unfortunately the opportunities to test various alternatives are dependant on conditions outside the chicken keepers control; one needs a broody hen, an appropriate alternative nesting box and the time and patience to observe and note the various outcomes. The main problem for me had been trying to reproduce what nature provides without any human assistance.

    It’s my intention to continue experimenting with soft base nest boxes.

    (Unfortunately I didn’t take any pictures while the turf base was in place. At that time I had no idea that I would be writing an article before I had finished experimenting and before I finished the book.)

    The picture below demonstrates the problem that some hens have with posture due to nest boxes constructed with a hard base. This is Fudge. She has been sitting on her eggs for two days. When she first started sitting both her legs were underneath her body and her body weight was supported by both legs. After some hours of trying to maintain body contact with her eggs the eggs moved from underneath her and formed a ring around her body and under her wings; one leg jutting out at an angle.
    P9261148 (Large).JPG

    Isolation coop with plywood base.

    P9251140 (Large).JPG

    Isolation coop with front in place
    P9251141 (Large).JPG

    Isolation coop with butile matt. I tried this to reduce egg breakages and give the hens feet more grip.
    P9251142 (Large).JPG

    Mel and Cillin not overly impressed with the nesting arrangement.
    P9251145 (Large).JPG

    Mel and Cillin creating a hollow in the ground in the run in preference to the coop.
    P9251143 (Large).JPG

    Nature, she’s a hard act to follow, even in material science.:)

    Share This Article

Recent User Reviews

  1. DobieLover
    "Very informative article!"
    5/5, 5 out of 5, reviewed Nov 1, 2018
    Thanks, Shadrack! This article has prompted me to change the design of my nest boxes when I do my shed to coop conversion this spring. Anything to make my chickens lives more natural and enjoyable.
    Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      Hello DobieLover.
      I'm pleased you liked the article. I
  2. k2panman
    "Great observations on nesting and well written!"
    5/5, 5 out of 5, reviewed Oct 27, 2018
    Thanks for a great article! As a newbie, I was wondering what the best nesting materials were. Your observations and conclusions make very good sense. I really appreciate you taking the time and sharing this information. I just put together a nestbox condo - 3 in a row - built with plywood. I think I’ll find some shallow containers (maybe dish pans) to fill with a piece of sod a few inches thick, and put one of these in each box. Mahalo for all your help!
    Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      Thanks for reading the article. Good luck with the pan and clod of earth idea.
  3. Bhapimama
    "So Interesting!"
    5/5, 5 out of 5, reviewed Oct 16, 2018
    It makes so much sense to try and replicate what hens would do naturally! Thank you so much for this informative article. Please let us know when you publish your book!
    Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      Thank you. The book is going very slowly but I intend to contact all thos e who have expressed an interest when its finished.


To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. libbie
    Interesting article. I wonder how putting a thick layer of construction sand (the same kind people put on the floors of their coops) in the nest box would work?
  2. Thomas Lamprogiorgos

    What breed is the first hen shown?
      Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      I don't really know. She was an incubator orphan, probably bantam, but which type of bantam I have no idea. Sorry.
      Thomas Lamprogiorgos likes this.
    2. Thomas Lamprogiorgos
      I want to create sth like this...
      Shadrach likes this.
  3. slordaz
    I have about a small bale of hay I keep on the floor where they seem to like to lay and one of my broodies even with the hard floor did fine as she's got a 4 ft by 4 ft area , she got her nest how she wanted it and is currently hatching out, she kicked the others out to the regular laying boxes even though that was where they generally liked to all lay. I think she chose that area because she's tried to brood before and some human critter messed with her on final 3 days and she felt safer there. My philosophy is they been doing it fine on their own let em keep on doing what works for them, this is her first successful hatch at a year and a half
      Shadrach and Col1948 like this.
  4. harmesonfarm
    Great article, thanks for sharing your findings.
    Makes sense!
      Shadrach likes this.
  5. Corys chickens
      Earthchick and Shadrach like this.
    1. Shadrach
      I have used freshly cut grass but it’s the earth base that makes the difference.
      Molpet likes this.
  6. Jonas Fox
    Neat information ^_^

    So is the moral of the story to give your girls a ton of shapeable material to work into a bowl? Or perhaps Shaping a bowl of not bone-dry earth in the nest boxes along with nesting material? Thanks for the insights!
      Shadrach likes this.
  7. eggup
    Interesting read!
      Shadrach likes this.
  8. Redhead Rae
    I find my hens like hay better than straw because it is moldable. If you give them a good 3-4 inches of hay, they will make a divot to nest in.
      Leahs Mom and Shadrach like this.
    1. Shadrach
      Thanks for reading.
      I can't use the hay here. It has species of mites living in it and they bite!
      Redhead Rae likes this.
    2. Redhead Rae
      Ah, I thought straw was bad for bedding because it is hollow in the center and can harbor mites. I don't have any issues with hay where I am.
      Shadrach likes this.
    3. Shadrach
      The best bedding, not base, I've found is fresh cut grass.
      Molpet and Leahs Mom like this.
  9. Henrik Petersson
    Chicken Keeping 1.01 is easy. Then there is a lot of Chicken Keeping 1.02. Heaps of tiny little details that maximize the success of your chicken keeping. When you've had chickens for a while, and you've got Chicken Keeping 1.01 down, it's fascinating to learn about the 1.02. This article is Chicken Keeping 1.02. Thank you.
      Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      Thank you for reading the article. And thank you for your kind comments. I have a few more articles partly written and I hope you'll find them equally interesting.
  10. Col1948
    I found that very interesting, also I'm wondering if having the top more open as in your pictures, so the hen can come and go without having to crouch to get in the nest.
    I have a hen that is laying soft shell eggs and I think the constriction of movement getting out of the nest box it a possible cause, before I got the nest boxes I used some cardboard boxes open at the top as a makeshift, they seemed to like them and went in willingly.
      Shadrach likes this.
    1. Shadrach
      The hens still come and go through the opening in the front wall. Normally there is a roof on the coop. I leave the roof off for periods of the day because there is some evidence that developing eggs benefit from exposure to daylight.
      This once again goes against the current trend to use broody coops in dark places.
  11. the cluck juggler
    Food for thought! Reading this, I realise many of my broodies have had the problem with eggs rolling away on hard, slippery floors. Must be frustrating for them, and I will most certainly be presenting them with better options next year.
      Shadrach likes this.
  12. townchicks
    This is a thoughtful and interesting article. It makes sense to me. I know that my ringneck dove will dip her chest into the water bowl before returning to the nest, I had read that it is to help with the humidity of the eggs. It makes me want to have a broody, just to watch, but, no roos here, so pointless, sadly.
  13. Fields Mountain Farm
    Very interesting and insightful article!
    I use nest boxes as well. And while I hadnt thought about the hens need for a better grip.. the boxes are quite deep with the front ledge of the opening being made intentionally higher than most Ive seen. I put damp soil in the bottom and cover with hay so they are able to make a bowl in the nest. I like the idea of a clod of dirt with plant material better tho...
    Thank you for your research and for sharing the results with us. I want my hens healthy and happy and I want them to be able to hatch comfortably and hatch healthy chicks... will definitely be making adjustments next season!
      Col1948, townchicks and Shadrach like this.
    1. View previous replies...
    2. Shadrach
      One more thing...what breed/s do you keep?
      Fields Mountain Farm likes this.
    3. Fields Mountain Farm
      Our climate is hot and humid during summer, rainy in spring and fall, cold and wet with occasional ice and snow in the peak of winter.
      As far as the dirt for a base, i noticed the hens would move much of the hay from the center leaving a wood surface and the eggs wouldnt sit quite right for their liking. They would seem to struggle with setting on all of them so I fugured a thick base of earth might help remedy this. It did but not as much as Id like. The dirt holds together well here due to humidity, I assume..They still struggle a bit to find a comfortable postion. I just hadnt found another solition until now, thanks to you. Lol
      townchicks and Shadrach like this.
    4. Fields Mountain Farm
      I have a mixed flock. Some French copper Marans, EEs, Ameracauna, Ayam Cemani, silkies, an ohikie roo, and some mixes of God only knows
      Shadrach likes this.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by: