I don't like the all natural peanut butter. I want to, but it separates into oil and a kind of non-Newtonian liquid (like cornstarch and water but way more obstinate). If you leave it alone it either settles or if you tilt it, flows. When you try to stir the oil back in, or even take a spoonfull out, it suddenly comes to life and fights back. It's literally easier to stir thick concrete. Tahini is worse; almond "butter" is easier to scoop. And when you, against all odds, manage a spoonful, it's dry.
I like commercial peanut butter. I prefer smooth but either is fine. I like a bit on a slice of cheddar, an apple slice, or just a spoonful straight--and yes it's heavenly with honey.