Out of my four EE chicks three are clearly cockerels. This one I have always thought was a pullet. Any time I have posted the pics of it everyone says pullet. Today I had a nice lady come over to see my chicks and tell me the sex. She has raised chickens for 30 yrs and judges show chickens. She took one look at it and said it was a cockerel. This chick was my last hope of having a pullet! I sure hope she was wrong. LOL.. Out of my 8 older chicks, seven are confirmed cockerels.
its black and white and every black and white ee i have seen either 1) had some other color added to it which made it a cockerel or 2) was just the black and white with no other coloration on them what so ever have always been pullets, plus the comb isnt nearlly as red as the others combs i can see. can you post pics of the others just in case or you want some more opions about them as well (plus i want to see some more pretty chickens lol)
if i am seeing it right both of your ee cockerels have a dirty/buff coloration to their hackles in which the pullet in question does not have...the buff yep deffently a cockerel (besides its crowing) it has that deep red on the wings of which only roosters get.
I vote EE in question is a hen not a roo as comb is not developing as others and no red coloring on shoulders. I got 8 straight run EE last year and 4 where roos and they where really pretty ones. Unfortunatly they had to go to freezer camp bc they where mean to hens.