2 Jersey Giants ?

[NinaJoy]

I found this picture on here and it's IDENTICAL to mine. This one was said to be a Black Australorp pullet. Tomorrow can't get here fast enough. Anyone like to bet? LOL. My money is on one Jersey Giant and One Black Australorp.
Now I feel dumb. They've always look different enough I could tell them apart no problem. Not like my same breed Golden Sex Links.

 

[human1]

I found this picture on here and it's IDENTICAL to mine. This one was said to be a Black Australorp pullet. Tomorrow can't get here fast enough. Anyone like to bet? LOL. My money is on one Jersey Giant and One Black Australorp.
Now I feel dumb. They've always look different enough I could tell them apart no problem. Not like my same breed Golden Sex Links.

lol...
my brain is exploding now

 

[EmmaRainboe]

I found this picture on here and it's IDENTICAL to mine. This one was said to be a Black Australorp pullet. Tomorrow can't get here fast enough. Anyone like to bet? LOL. My money is on one Jersey Giant and One Black Australorp.
Now I feel dumb. They've always look different enough I could tell them apart no problem. Not like my same breed Golden Sex Links.

She definetly looks like a black australorp. But if she has yellow feet she is probably a Jersey Giant. Let us know tomorrow! Although if she does have yellow feet, could just be a bad quality australorp. Hatcheries - especially this year, don't have very high quality birds.

 

[human1]

She definetly looks like a black australorp. But if she has yellow feet she is probably a Jersey Giant. Let us know tomorrow! Although if she does have yellow feet, could just be a bad quality australorp. Hatcheries - especially this year, don't have very high quality birds.

okay, now my brain isnt exploding as much

 

[NinaJoy]

lol...
my brain is exploding now

Saaaame. I ran out to the coop with my phone as a flashlight. My rooster who freaks me out was blocking her so I couldn't grab her from the only angle I could reach.

 

[EmmaRainboe]

She definetly looks like a black australorp. But if she has yellow feet she is probably a Jersey Giant. Let us know tomorrow! Although if she does have yellow feet, could just be a bad quality australorp. Hatcheries - especially this year, don't have very high quality birds.

Although I will add, would be the same the other way around. If it doesn't have yellow feet could still be a hatchery quality Jersey Giant.

 

[Acre4Me]

FWIW, the one on the left looks like she has white earlobes or white in her earlobes. Black Australorps have red earlobes. Could be a mixed breed like an EE or OE or similar type "breed" that is really just a mix. Scruffy feather - sometimes means male before obvious saddle feathers come in, but yours would already be showing saddle feathers by this time, so they are female. Some birds have scruffy feathers like that.

 

[NinaJoy]

Interesting update. These two pictures are from the pullet on the left (left meaning from the original photo). Feet don't look yellow to me. Took a shit of her face/side too.

 

[EmmaRainboe]

Interesting update. These two pictures are from the pullet on the left (left meaning from the original photo). Feet don't look yellow to me. Took a shit of her face/side too.

Hmm... could be a black australorp, or hatchery quality Jersey Giant.

@Overo Mare thoughts?

 

[NinaJoy]

These two are the pullet on the right. Her feet don't look yellow either. What is going in here...