Wow, great post, chooks4life!
I have a rooster who is dinner waiting to happen. He is my only adult rooster and is a superb flock rooster--watchful for predators, able to teach ditzy Polish to move to a fence line when there is an alarm, and polite to the hens. I've kept him solely to protect my free range flock. He would be perfect if he wasn't aggressive to people.
He's an Ameraucana from a top breeder. Last year, I raised about five cockerels from that breeder: a blue, a splash, two wheatens and a blue wheaten. The wheatens breeding lines would have been completely separate lines from the blue and splash birds.
The blue and splash cockerels are/were quite people aggressive. The splash ended up in the freezer at about 9 months. The blue is a gorgeous specimen and I needed a rooster to guard the hens, so he is still alive. The blue wheaten was rehomed to my neighbor who since got rid of him because of "too many hormones" in the yard, as she put it. The two wheatens were culled at 9 months without showing any people aggression. They were the very bottom of the cockerel pecking order.
I have this one rooster with my free range flock who is only alive until the 7 four-month old cockerels from the same breeder are grown up enough to take over the role of flock protectors. I intend to grow out a few of these cockerels to use for breeding and showing. I've just recently integrated the juvenile Ameraucanas into free range flock (7 cockerels, 5 pullets). They are still off on their own and haven't yet been incorporated into the rooster's very small flock although he does watch them. I believe if something attacked them, he would come running.
I'm starting to worry about getting attacked in the face. I hate that I am basically abusing this animal because if he attacks, I will kick him, hit him with something or grab him and stuff his face into the ground like a rooster would do. Bottom line, this is animal abuse in my mind. I hate being afraid to walk around my property. He HAS to go, but I don't want to leave my 12 ditzy 4-month old Ameraucanas, two Polish (that the rooster trained to be a lot more watchful than they were when I put first them out with him), and a bantam without a rooster to watch over them.
However, he is getting really dangerous. I can see him killing one of my mini Dachshunds, although a few floggings from him have been a very good lesson for them to learn.
When do young cockerels start being protective?
I really think I need to cull him even though I won't have a proper guarding rooster.
Thanks for your thoughts.